StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Hidden intellectualism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of the essay "Hidden intellectualism" analyzes the article by Gerald Graff. The author tries to explore how the students who do not perform well in school are inherently not intellectuals. This is based on the street smarts that most students pose when they are out of the school…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Hidden intellectualism"

 Hidden Intellectualism The hidden intellectualism by Gerald Graff is the article where the author tries to explore how the students who do not perform well in school are inherently not intellectuals. This is based on the street smarts that most students pose when they are out of the school. He explores the way the street marts are just, but academic pursuits, and not intellectuals. He asserts that people have the cultural respect to the education that is institutionalized and not the education outside the institution (Graff, 2010). He presents the way individuals view the street marts to be non-academicians and value the education, basing on the academics, mind very narrowly focusing on the subjects and the texts that appear weighty and academic. He argues against these suggestions, and supports the fact that even the fields we consider not intellectuals are intellectuals. He asserts that the issue of the street marts can be very helpful in sparking the student’s interests towards the academic pursuit leading to very good performance. Generally, Graff supports intellectualism in the street smart students (Graff, 2010). I believe this is true; I have tried the same and come to realize that I will not consider myself biased as I present the paper concerning Graff’s arguments. For instance, Graff uses the illustrations of the sports and the magazines to support his points. Though his examples may not be applicable to everyone, but to some individuals. For me, I would have expounded on the idea of the based on the teaching also in school. For instance, he would have said that the street-smart students are also scholarly (Graff, 2010). Deborah Tannen Her writings are based on the way work fights for the individual’s lives. She critically analyzes some of the cultural aspects of life that influence people. She refers to a habit as an argument culture. She asks people to look at the world from an adverse point of view. She asserts that the best method of approaching ideas, conversations is in the form of a debate. She illustrates these with examples of company news, the company that looks for the news anchors who can show extremely odd views so that they can present the two sides of the situation. She argues the way, such a culture is the day-to-day routine that the public interactions are used, and to them they believe the way one thinks. According to her, an individual has to pose a debate so that the other individuals can agree or disagree to the point. However, moderation should also be applied when it comes to a debate. This is because even the debates have their own purpose, though they are not the only options of understanding and viewing the world. According to Tannen, people’s culture is based on the personal habits and arguments that seek the winning and losing end. She states that when it comes to the conflict for instance, there must be an opposing and proposing side, and in this case, there must be a disagreement and agreement (Tannen 2010). According to her, it only destroys the society and sets people in the battle mindset situations whereby every battle must lead to hurting. She emphasizes that it only makes people think for irrelevant rhetorical limitations from the opposing end, instead of listening to the important issues. She argues and views agonizing response as the planned contentiousness, pre-patterned, without thinking, and involves fighting so that one can reach his or her goal, and this directs the whole society in that direction. She illustrates the consequences of the whole thing based on her observation, which supports the facts that this leads to the trends of opposition that destroys our society. She asserts that the society is full of connections and authorities, alienations, forms and habits of the communities leading to a detached state that is full of hostility (Tannen 2010). I do agree with Tannen, but she fails to give the alternatives to the issues she bases on in her writing. She assumes that debates are the best way of solving issues. Chapter: I take your point, Entering Classroom Discussion This chapter 11 deals with the way class discussions influence the student’s performance. They assert that it is not just a matter of discussion, but every group member should be geared towards one goal on. It calls for the application of what they have learned in the classroom, as well as the other academic writings. It also involves framing the mind of an individual while trying to make a response. They have to connect with the previous speaker on page 142. They assert that as a writer, she or he has to involve other writers by mentioning them, they should explain in details to make the reader to understand the points clearly without having to go back and read the whole book that is being referred (Ferguson, 2013). They talk about how people looking at an argument from both sides. That is, one should see the writer’s argument and relate it on the individual's point of view (p. 147). This helps the reader to be an active participant while reading. There should be a better imagery of writing than steals the reader’s imaginations. The authors assert that the students always miss that point, they only ventriloquism the views that we do not believe in them. The arguments that can be discussed, but we go ahead to accept them, yet we have other points to argue against. On page 150, the author states that, this is applied in most of the texts and essays. He illustrates that “when they said I say is about something nobody talked about” chapter 12 talks the way the readers have to get involved in the reading, put there, how the reader has to set, an argument that can attract criticism as well as give options to the audience (Ferguson, 2013). The authors are all on the same line as the main point here is based on the academics and academicians, and the ways to be not just an academician, but also as an intellectual. The hidden intellectualism by Gerald Graff is the article where the author tries to explore how the students who do not perform well in school are inherently not intellectuals. This is based on the street smarts that most students pose when they are out of the school. While chapter twelve talks about how people looking at an argument from both sides. Tannen states that one should see the writer’s argument and relate it on the individual’s point of view. Her writings are based on the way work fights for the individual’s lives. She critically analyzes some of the cultural aspects of life that influence people. She refers to a habit as an argument culture. References Ferguson, Dianne L. (2013) “Working Together: Groupwork, Teamwork, and Collaborative Work among Teachers.” Urban school. National Institute for Urban School Improvement Graff, Gerald. (2010) “Hidden Intellectualism."  They Say, I Say. 2nd Ed.  Eds.  Graff, Gerald   and Birkenstein, Cathy. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 198-205. Print. Tannen, Deborah. (2010.) Agonism in the Academy: Surviving the Argument Culture. 2nd edition. W. W. Norton % Company, Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Hidden intellectualism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 4”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1643070-response-essay
(Hidden Intellectualism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 4)
https://studentshare.org/education/1643070-response-essay.
“Hidden Intellectualism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 4”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1643070-response-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Hidden intellectualism

Fahrenheit 451 Novel

This is followed by a strange occurrence that he encounters as he responds to an alarm about an old woman who has a stash of hidden books.... Fahrenheit 451 Name: Toni Rogers ENG320 Q52012 Fahrenheit 451 Fahrenheit 451 is a dystopian novel that was written in 1953 by Ray Bradbury....
11 Pages (2750 words) Term Paper

The American Dream

Consequently, this has prompted numerous spiritual intellectuals stating the actual hidden meaning of the dream as “greed, capitalism and failure of spirituality” evidenced in the America presently (Lillie 36).... The American Dream essay example depicts a set of ideals held by Americans concerning their social forward mobility....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Playboy of the Western World

Fin de Siecle or End of the Century, often used as a synonym, referring to last years of 19th century, and mirrors the garbled period of unhappiness, uncertainty, political upheavals building up for First World War, and the human and intellectual attempts to come of the hurdles, by ushering in acute changes in art and humanistic fields, etc....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Plagiarism is a Vice

It is one of the greatest challenges to the advancement of knowledge and the growth of intellectualism.... That is simply plagiarism but with a hidden motive.... The researcher states plagiarism is a vice that raises much concern in most academic areas and even beyond....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Gerald Graffs Hidden Intellectualism

In Graff's “Hidden intellectualism” article, the author is quick to indicate that knowledge is much more than academic learning in the classroom setting and that learning is a process that is continuous in the ‘outside' world.... This results to Graff's argument that sports presented more intellect than school Gerald Graff's “Hidden intellectualism” Gerald Graff's “Hidden intellectualism” In Graff's “Hidden intellectualism” article, the author is quick to indicate that knowledge is much more than academic learning in the classroom setting and that learning is a process that is continuous in the ‘outside' world....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

The Theme of Illusion and Deception in Good Country People

hellip; In “Good Country People” by Flannery O'Connor, the hidden truth is reflected unambiguously through the reality in the story.... Good Country PeopleIn “Good Country People” by Flannery O'Connor, the hidden truth is reflected unambiguously through the reality in the story....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Intellectuals and Revolutionary Politics

According to this assignment, there are different opinions on George Sorel, varying from 'one of the two sole original thinkers thrown up by socialism' - of Benedetto Croce, through Mussolini's acknowledgment – 'What I am, I owe to Sorel'.... Somehow solitary stands Talmon's description of George Sorel....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

The Argument That Street Smarts Should Not Be Overlooked in Gerald Graff's Hidden Intellectualism

This essay is "The Argument That Street Smarts Should Not Be Overlooked in Gerald Graff's Hidden intellectualism".... nbsp;In his influential article “Hidden intellectualism”, Gerald Graff ensures that the attitude to students with “street smarts” should not be negative, as they may succeed in the expression of the skills that relate not only to studying literature.... In his article, the author is focused on the argument that street smarts should not be overlooked; in Gerald Graff's “Hidden intellectualism” this opinion is supported by the principles of common sense and logical correspondence to realities, as well as numerous examples from the school environment....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us