StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Use of Animals for Scientific Research - Report Example

Cite this document
Summary
According to research findings of the paper “Use of Animals for Scientific Research”, the different sides to the debate surrounding the use of animals are espoused by groups that have extremely different goals and interests. A common point needs to be reached…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
Use of Animals for Scientific Research
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Use of Animals for Scientific Research"

Use of Animals for Scientific Research Your First Your Submitted Use of Animals for ScientificResearch There are various sides to the debate surrounding the use of animals for the purpose of scientific research. many may defend this practice citing the utilitarian perspective that would justify this practice because of the obvious benefits that it provides to humans who can then develop drugs and methods of treatment that are viable for testing upon humans. The rescue of many human lives may be seen as the reason behind the use of animals for scientific research that may provide one with a better understanding of living processes. This may ultimately lead to a better understanding of the human body and its processes. Supporters of the use of animals in scientific research cite the death of a negligible number of animals for the greater good of humanity which would be afforded better medical care that would improve the average life expectancy of people and also the quality of life that people experience. The other side of the debate is however, equally strong. Supporters of the opposite point of view argue that while looking to save more human lives in a strictly utilitarian and commercial manner, one must not lose sight of the ethical aspects that need to be looked into as a part of this issue. Whether man has the right to take the life of another organism for his own purposes is an extremely difficult question to answer and the need for the humane treatment of animals would require that the lives of innocent animals be spared, even though the resulting world may be a less comfortable one for human beings. This argument lays stress on the rights of animals to exist and on their equal rights to the resources of the world and at the very least, their very own lives. In certain cases, animal lives may be lost due to nothing more than negligence on the part of authorities and scientists. This paper shall seek to identify the questions that are a part of this issue and the multiple positions that are taken by the different parties involved in the debate. The deaths that are caused due to negligence and to test the effectiveness of weapons such as bombs are often avoidable. The history of the debate that is under discussion in this paper, according to Kristin Sharon Shrader-Frechette, in the modern world begins from the debates that surrounded the death of farm animals during the testing of atomic bombs in Nevada in May, 1953 (Shrader-Frechette, 1994). Litigation on this matter brought to the public consciousness the issue of animal welfare and the ethical treatment of animals. While the presence of sheep in the vicinity of a bomb test may not strictly qualify as the use of animals for scientific research, it does bring in the question of how animals are dragged into scientific activity where their death is caused by negligence of basic safety measures that would be put in place for humans. The fact that this case was brought to the court primarily because of the financial losses that were suffered on the part of the owners of the livestock proves how much society as a whole is concerned about the rights of animals. Even when there is no possibility of saving human lives, animals do get caught in a crossfire-like situation that causes loss of lives. An important reason as to why conflicts of most kinds remain unsolved is the lack of communication between the different parties that are involved in the process of debate. This gap in communication leads to various misunderstandings that can complicate an already complex issue. This can lead to various obstacles in the path of a possible solution to the problem. This is precisely the problem that prevents the rise of a possible solution to the problem that is under consideration in this paper. Tom L. Beauchamp points out this problem when he talks of the gap in communication that arises between the different partners involved in the debate about the humane treatment of animals and their use in scientific research. According to Beauchamp, these parties comprise the media, scientists and the general public which has a great influence upon the process of decision-making and on what the media chooses to report. The public often sends out an emotional response that is unable to take all facets of the discussion into account and ends up issuing untenable solutions without practical frameworks that would lead to a solution. Scientists, however, more often than not, refuse to communicate with either the media or the public and this is mostly due to indifference regarding public opinion or arrogance (Beauchamp, 2007). This is a self-defeating attitude, since it neither leads to a solution nor does it help in the smooth progress of scientific research since in the long run, the funding of projects do depend to a certain extent upon the public perception regarding issues. The rights of animals is one such issue that if left unsolved, can actually be detrimental to both science and the lives of countless animals. The need of the hour is thus, that the parties who are a part of this debate are brought to the negotiating table where a solution may be worked out. The viability of this solution may depend on how much each party is willing to compromise. To ensure smooth negotiations, members of the political establishment may step in as mediators. This would also make the transition from discussions to legislations a seamless one and one that is able to avoid too many complications. A paper on animal welfare by D. Fraser, D. M. Weary, E. A. Pajor and B. N. Milligan suggests taking into account the different adaptations that may have been made by animals due to changes in the environment. This paper goes on to suggest taking into account the subjective experiences of animals into account that presently is taken to fall outside the scope of scientific research (1997). Taking into account the needs of animals as seen in today’s world, which has a different environment than what was there a century ago is important in a discussion that seeks to ensure the safety and ethical treatment of animals while not losing track of the problems that this may cause for scientific research. A clear understanding of the need to produce medicines that would be effective in treating diseases that are presently incurable is necessary to understand the need for scientific research. At the same time, the concerns of activists and the general public which feels strongly about the rights of animals must be taken into account while policies are framed in this regard. The active cooperation of the political structure of a country is also necessary while implementing the changes that come out of discussions. Without the cooperation of the politicians and the law-making bodies of a country, the discussions are likely to produce results that would not last, since the presence of a third party that would be able to mediate the proceedings with a certain amount of authority is desirable, or even necessary, in these cases. The different sides to the debate surrounding the use of animals in scientific research are espoused by groups that have extremely different goals and interests. A common point needs to be reached that would enable either party’s side to be heard so that ways to protect the interests of either are sought. The need for negotiations is thus, paramount so that neither science nor innocent animal lives suffer. References Shrader-Frechette, Kristin Sharon. (1994). Ethics of scientific research. London: Rowman and Littlefield. Beauchamp, Tom L. (2007). The Moral Standing of Animals in Medical Research. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics. 20 (1-2). Retrieved February 3, 2012, from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1748-720X.1992.tb01169.x/abstract Fraser D., Weary D.M., Pajor, E. A., Milligan, B.N. (1997). A Scientific Conception of Animal Welfare that Reflects Ethical Concerns. Animal Welfare. 6. Retrieved February 3, 2012, from http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/user_upload/animalwelfare/Fraser1997.pdf Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Use of Animals for Scientific Research Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Use of Animals for Scientific Research Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1765853-the-researched-recommendation-paper-using-the-classical-mode-of-argument
(Use of Animals for Scientific Research Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Use of Animals for Scientific Research Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1765853-the-researched-recommendation-paper-using-the-classical-mode-of-argument.
“Use of Animals for Scientific Research Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1765853-the-researched-recommendation-paper-using-the-classical-mode-of-argument.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Use of Animals for Scientific Research

Why does Ruse say that Creationism should not be understood as a Science

This last criticism feels pejorative and one cannot help noting some use of an ad hominem circumstantial fallacy as Ruse offers no evidence that Christian scientists are less than objective.... Finally, Ruse looks at The Creation research Institute which he says that a condition for membership in this society is acknowledgement, by signing, that the bible is literally true.... scientific creationism (which will be used interchangeably with creation-science) is the scientific explanation and vindication of the creation story....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Psychological Approaches Of Modern Psychology

n approach is… ly a perspective or view that involves particular assumptions based on certain beliefs regarding the behavior of humans, the study of some of their aspects and the research methods which are appropriate for undertaking the study.... n approach is basically a perspective or view that involves particular assumptions based on certain beliefs regarding the behavior of humans, the study of some of their aspects and the research methods which are appropriate for undertaking the study....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Languages and Evolution

My research paper, however, will address the impact of vocal… The research question involves whether vocal imitation could be a linchpin of a critical change in human language in the future.... I intend to support my position in this mini-research through several arguments.... The report stated the widely recognized principle that humans especially children learn new words based from what they hear others use them in conversations....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Proposal

OUTLINE ASSIGNMENT

Traditional wound care entails the use of natural… The advances in medicine has prompted doctors to revisit the traditional methods of wound healing that used natural products in wound care.... Essential oils have shown excellent Outline TOPIC OUTLINE Thesis ment: The use of natural wound care in treating diabetes wounds is more effective than the use of traditional wound care.... Healing of wounds in patients with DiabetesSENTENCE OUTLINEThesis: The use of natural wound care in treating diabetes wounds is more effective than the use of traditional wound care....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Conservation

research also shows their importance in lowering risks in cancer and arthritis.... The scientific name is Pagophilus groenlandicus.... Bacteria that cause brucellosis are Gram-negative with the dominating species in marine animals being Brucella pinipediae and Brucella cetaceae....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Animal Behavior: Evolution

The social behavior of these species still requires further research as it has not been an area of central focus among ethologists.... ature/nurture controversy has also been widely discussed in the scientific department as it involves numerous aspects of human life.... Judging from this concept the weaker species are incapable of learning to use their defective or disadvantaged phenotypes and these features are lost from the gene pool.... n the absence of evolution, organisms would be able to adapt to features that are in their genetic pool and use them to attain an environmental advantage....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The Evolution of Flight in Birds

Nevertheless, these are just mere believes that have not been backed by any scientific data or evidence, thus remains just theoretical explanations of the evolution of flight in birds, requiring that more scientific and well-grounded explanations should be developed.... hellip; The high speed developed into frantic flapping, which combined with the wind currents caused the animals to get airborne (Burgers & Chiappe, 1999).... Therefore, the initial ancestors of the birds had strong legs and weaker wings, since it is the legs rather than the wings that enabled the animals to run....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Proposal
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us