StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Founding and the Constitution - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
1. Article V of the Constitution of the United States defines the procedure for altering the document’s contents, primarily consisting of the proposal of an amendment followed by its ratification. Two ways of proposing amendments are described in Article V, the first being the…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
The Founding and the Constitution
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Founding and the Constitution"

1. Article V of the Constitution of the United s defines the procedure for altering the document’s contents, primarily consisting of the proposal of an amendment followed by its ratification. Two ways of proposing amendments are described in Article V, the first being the normal procedures of any lawmaking in the legislative branch. In this first method (the “formal method”), the United States Congress proposes an amendment, which requires agreement from a super majority (defined as two-thirds of voting members) in each house.

Super majority is required given the absolute nature of laws written into the Constitution, so the document is laying out a requirement that seeks a high standard of judgment. Also, the Constitution requires super majority votes from both the Senate as well as the House because, in theory, the two parts of the legislature were meant to represent different interests and different people (the Senate representing more of the small, rural states, which get to send two Senators in all cases whereas the House representing more of the populous states, which get to send representatives on the basis of population) (Alder).

The second procedure (the “informal method”) for proposing amendments to the Constitution provides protection for states to an unresponsive Congress. If two-thirds of states agree to call for a convention, the Congress is obliged to call a convention. This method has neither constitutional instruction for how to complete the convention nor precedent to be relied upon. It is not clear whether the states would be represented equally or by population. With that said, all amendments to the Constitution have been carried out through the first procedure described.

The Founders may have wanted this second procedure as a way of empowering the states and protecting against an intrusive, federal government (Mount).2. “Loose construction” refers to a loose or liberal interpretation of the U.S. Constitution, thus expanding federal powers beyond those explicitly mentioned in the document. In contrast, “strict construction” refers to the opposite: it is a legal philosophy that requires the interpreter of the Constitution to apply the text only as it is written.

In other words, powers not enumerated in the Constitution are invalid (Welch).As was described previously, the formal method of amendment has a clear process described in the Constitution, which maps onto the normal procedure for business of the Congress in creating laws. Therefore, the formal method of amendment is consistent with a strict constructionist approach to the document. On the other hand, the informal method of amendment’s exact procedure is not clearly defined by Article V and therefore requires some interpretation, which is most consistent with the loose constructionist approach to the Constitution.

So far, all proposed Amendments to the Constitution have been through the formal approach and therefore consistent with a strict constructionist view.3. One can see loose construction and strict construction as two extremes in a case where common sense, moderate viewpoints are preferable. Loose construction is problematic in the sense that the Constitution can be misused by activists to enforce new interpretations and value-judgments on the American people. Also, since the Founders provided a process of Amending the Constitution, one can assume they did not intend for the words and their interpretation in the document to change.

Strict construction is problematic also in the sense that the world has changed since its creation in the late 18th century. Concepts and social dynamics in the document may no longer apply and therefore it should be interpreted loosely. Also, the Founders did not provide guidance on interpretation and therefore it can be assumed that there is no one way to interpret it, which is against strict constructionism. The best textural approach to the Constitution would seek to follow an explicit, strict approach but only up until the point where the strict approach offers insufficient guidance, at which point an interpretive, loose approach is best.

Works CitedAlder, Gary. "Article V – The Amendment Process." n.d. In Search of the American Constitutional Paradigm. http://www.freedomformula.us/constitution/the-constitution-by-section/article-v-the-amendment-process/. 2014.Mount, Steve. "Constitutional Amendments." 30 January 2010. U.S. Constitution. http://www.usconstitution.net/constam.html. 2014.Welch, Hillard W. "Strict Construction vs Loose Construction." n.d. The John Birch Society. http://www.jbs.org/constitution-blog/strict-construction-vs-loose-construction. 2014.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Founding and the Constitution Research Paper”, n.d.)
The Founding and the Constitution Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1643567-the-founding-and-the-constitution
(The Founding and the Constitution Research Paper)
The Founding and the Constitution Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/history/1643567-the-founding-and-the-constitution.
“The Founding and the Constitution Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1643567-the-founding-and-the-constitution.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Founding and the Constitution

Germany's Political Situation

Amendments to the constitution require 66% majority votes from the chambers of parliament.... The fundamental principles of the German constitution express human dignity, federal structures, and separation of power and rule of law as valid in perpetuity.... Each state has a constitution, and they are largely autonomous with regard to internal organization....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Understanding the U.S. Constitution

Others claim the constitution is a living document.... hellip; This assignment will begin with the statement that the constitution is the greatest source of laws in not only the United States but also in other nations of the world.... As the paper outlines, there are mainly three groups of people where the constitution is involved.... The first group subscribes to the theory that the constitution should be based on original intent, the others insist that it should be based on textualism and the rest insist that the constitution is a living document and hence subject to changes and other amendments (Isaacs 5)....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Development in the Current System of the U.S. Government from the Point of View of the Founding Fathers

nbsp; Changes in the constitution can have a lot of repercussions for the countrymen.... The Founding Fathers are those who framed the constitution and had a say in the Declaration of Independence.... Drafting the constitution was no minor responsibility.... Their far-reaching political experience and the sweat they put in making the constitution would make them reluctant to accept changes in it.... the constitution was laid down with seven major articles, one each for legislative power, executive power, judicial power, states' powers and limits, a process of amendments, federal power, and ratification....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

A Wall of Separation between Law and Religion

In the paper “A Wall of Separation between Law and Religion” the author treads on the path of James Madison, the Father of the constitution, who exhorted us to “arm ourselves with the power that knowledge gives.... In the opinion of Justice Hugo Black and others, the founding Fathers sought to raise an impregnable 'wall of separation' between government and religious faith when they adopted the First Amendment.... The common view is that “from the first day of the United States until today, the Supreme Court has been pivotal in interpreting our constitution and shaping our republic....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

The Delegates to the Constitutional Convention

However, the Convention presided over by George Washington resulted in the formulation of the United States' constitution.... The 55 delegates from various regions attended the convention and actively participated in the inception of the new constitution.... All had extensive knowledge and political experiences, for among the delegates, people like 'Baldwin, Bassett, Bedford, Dickinson, Few, Franklin, Ingersoll, Livingston, Alexander Martin, Luther Martin, Mercer, Gouverneur Morris, Robert Morris, Read, Sherman, and Williamson' had already lived or worked in more than one state or colony (America's founding Fathers)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Powers Vested on the Central Government of the US

Based on the nature of the constitution and the provisions on the powers of the federal government, the American system has created a limited government scenario as the mandate of the federal government are limited by the fundamental constitutional provisions (Ginsberg, Lowi and Weir 47).... hellip; The nature of the distribution of powers in the US has created a limited constitution kind of government in which the powers of the national government are limited only to specific areas that are of national interest....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Business Memo: The Theory of the Declaration and the Constitution

The central principles that were The Theory of the Declaration and the constitution Constitution 101 (the meaning and history ofthe constitution) was particularly eye opening.... The central principles that were entrenched within the constitution, as embodied by the declarations of independence, were derived from a fundamental understanding of human nature that formulated a universal approach towards formulation of regulations and laws.... This formulated the core foundation of the constitution....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

The Issues In The Preamble To The Constitution Of 1787

The paper "The Issues In The Preamble To the constitution Of 1787" analyzes How did the events of the first three decades of the American Republic reflect the issues enumerated in the Preamble to the constitution of 1787.... The supreme court of America was later to be given the responsibility defending and interpreting the constitution.... How did the events of the first three decades of the American Republic reflect the issues enumerated in the Preamble to the constitution of 1787?...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us