StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Commercial Law - Abe Transport Pty - Case Study Example

Summary
From the paper "Commercial Law - Abe Transport Pty " it is clear that Rob was doing what he was entitled to do and his activities were within the employment scope and contract as he was reversing his truck up the loading bay when he accidentally backed over his brother. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Commercial Law - Abe Transport Pty"

Business Commercial Law Name Institution Question 1 Court Experience As observed in the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court during a tour of the court to observe and study court proceedings and the set up, I was perplexed by the sublime sense of lighting, which permeates the court building and the architectural developments, which exhibited the French Romanesque style. The amazing observation about the court is the inclusion of three courtrooms within the same premises, contrary to my expectations. The three courtrooms were Central inner Courtyard, Stair hall and the Spectacular Octagonal entry. At the time of my entry, there was an ongoing court hearing, which sent mixed emotions pertaining to how the justice system operates and how it affects the victim and the accused. The proceedings triggered several questions on how legal systems operate especially when handling recurring acts of domestic violence. From my observation, I felt the need for significant improvements to the appellate process project to expedite any appeal processes for the hearing and determination of matters involving parental rights as well as to enhance the attorney’s involvement in the corresponding appeals. Hearing Room In the hearing room, I observed several features including a raised desk known as the bench where the judges sat with plain black robes. There was also a witness stand, just adjacent to the bench and another desk occupied by the reporter and the clerk of the hearing room. The room is divided into two parts by a barrier referred to as the bar where the bailiff is sitting on one side to maintain law and order in the hearing room. On the other side of the bench is a table for the plaintiff, the defendant, and their corresponding counsel. There is also a group of seats referred to as the jury box occupied by the jury. There is an open space between the counsel table and the bench, which separates the reporter, clerk, and the jury box. This space is known as the well. I learned that it is disrespectful to the court if any person who is not an employee of the court to directly or indirectly traverse the well. The other side of the bar has been opened for the general public. Personnel in the Hearing Room In the hearing room, there are lawyers representing the interests of distinct interested parties, who sit at the bar table. There are also court officers who administer an affirmation or an oath to the witnesses. A court monitor types some parts of what is being said while the rest is electronically recorded. In addition, there are witnesses allowed to occupy the witness box in readiness to testify before the court. On the other hand, members of the public occupy the public gallery and are not allowed to interrupt or talk to the court. The media is also present and is allowed the freedom to gather any information that may be of interest to them regarding the court proceedings and the ruling. Cases heard by the Civil List The types of cases heard by the civil list include general civil jurisdiction which covers matters that revolve around debt claims, damages (both liquidated and unliquidated) for cases involving breach of contract, any damage of property and civil action for any discrimination under the Occupational Health and Safety Act of 2004. The court also hears cases involving work cover jurisdiction issues, which entails workplace injuries as per the Accident Compensation Act of 1985 or the workers compensation act of 1958. The Magistrates court can also hear and determine cases over property or money whose value does not exceed $100,000 even though it may hear cases of unlimited value in some specific circumstances. Under the industrial jurisdiction, the court may hear claims between employees and employers or deal with matters contained in the Long Service Leave Act of 1992. Commencing and Defending an Action in the Court The first step in commencing an action involves filing a complaint with the court, which is forthwith followed by issuance of summons. Subsequently, documents that support the court claim should be prepared and delivered to the court (both the original and a copy). This may be done by posting them via fax, sending them via the internet, or handing them over to the registry. The registry staff will then check the documents to verify whether they comply with the legislation under which the application has been commenced. The documents will then be stamped after which a filing fee will be paid. A defendant may defend an action in court by filing a defense notice with an attached defense statement along with two similar copies (both originals). The defendants will also explain the reason as to why they think they should file for a defense where the case will either be dismissed or referred to another court. It is inadvisable for the defendant to defend a court action based on the principle alone. Other things that should be involved are the likelihood of success, evidence needed to substantiate the case and whether the party being claimed from will be in a position pay up when they lose (Gillies, 2004). Facts on the Ongoing Case I appeared in court to observe a case that involved domestic violence where the accused was under house confinement for the assaults of his resonance on the victim’s direction. The case took place in the Central inner Courtyard courtroom and involved the crown of attorney, the victim, the judge and the accused as well as his lawyer. The victim was a young individual who had many recurring violence patterns and persistently disobeying his probation orders. This was after the victim had called the police to notify them that the victim (who happened to be drinking in a hotel) had breached his conditional sentence. Laws Governing the Case The laws governing this case are that anybody ought to apply for domestic violence order if confronted with any (Humphreys & Stanley 2006). This is outlined in the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012. The act exists as provision of safety for individuals in relevant relationships, who happen to be victims of either family or domestic violence. The act has defined relevant relationships as family relationships, spousal relationships or informal care relationships. The Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 have replaced the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 1989 by providing a contemporary definition of what might constitute of domestic violence (Summers 2002). The law was applied in the proceedings of the domestic violence case by establishing the existence of an informal care relationship that subsists between the victim and the claimant. Application and Outcome The court found that article 2 (right to life) was violated as the accused was now becoming a threat to the victim whose prayer to the court was to have the accused finished his conditional sentence while in custody. Moreover, in alteration of the probation order, in order to reduce the victim’s fear, the victim may be arrested by the police and taken into community jail. The Victim eventually won the case notwithstanding the persistent efforts by the defense lawyer to fight the crown on any attempts to rule in favor of the victim. He lost the case because the victim has right to life (article 2) which nobody should violate or threaten by any means necessary. I felt that this was a fair decision as it complied with the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012. Question 2 Case Issue In this case, Rob is involved in a contractual relationship with Abe Transport Pty Ltd where he works as a driver. This implies a master/ servant relationship between the two parties (Best & Barnes, 2007). In addition, Rob’s brother works with the same company under the field of transport operations and the nature of their employment contracts require them to work together. However, it happened that Rob was reversing the track up the loading bay when he accidentally backed over his brother. Rule The case facts as presented in this question are embedded on the concept of vicarious liability. Vicarious liability is defined as the liability of one person to be held liable on behalf of the other. The proponents of vicarious liability outline that an employer is liable for all torts conducted by his workers in circumstances where there exists a master/servant relationship between the two parties and where the tort committed has occurred in the course of the employment contract (Cane 1997). However, an employer will not be liable for torts committed by his employees if they are beyond the scope of their corresponding employment contracts unless the employer authorizes such acts expressly or decides to ratify them. Moreover, an employer cannot claim that he appointed a competent person in cases where the legal duty is incumbent on the “master” to partake a specific task efficiently and the person (contractor) performs the task imperfectly. The employer is not held liable for the torts performed by his employees only when the liability involves strict liability (Best & Barnes, 2007). This is the only exception and it was well articulated in the case of Ryland’s v Fletcher (1866) . Application and Conclusion Abe Transport Pty will be held vicariously liable for the torts of his employees so long as they occurred in the course of the employment contract. Rob was doing what he was entitled to do and his activities were within the employment scope and contract as he was reversing his truck up the loading bay when he accidentally backed over his brother. Moreover, a master / servant relationship exists between Robb and Abe Transport Pty because he is employed under a contract of service and acts as per the orders of his employer. Abe Transport Pty should therefore be held liable for Rob’s torts because he satisfies the implied conditions of being an employee of the company and backed over his brother in the course of his employment contract. However, Abe Transport Pty would not have been liable if Robb was an independent contractor. In case law, cases which have had a similar ruling are, Lister v Ramford Ice and Cold Storage Co. Ltd (1967) and Storey v Ashton (1859). References Best, A., & Barnes, D. W. (2007). Basic tort law: Cases, statutes, and problems. Austin: Wolters Kluwer Law & Business. Cane, P. (1997). The anatomy of tort law. Oxford: Hart Publ. Damiano D L (2014). Licensed To kill: A defense of Vicarious Liability under the Endangered Species Act, 63, retrieved from http://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3423&context=dlj Gillies, P. (2004), Business law, Sydney: Federation Press Humphreys, C., & Stanley, N. (2006), Domestic violence and child protection: Directions for good practice. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Summers, R. W. (2002), Domestic violence: A global view. Westport, Conn. [u.a.: Greenwood Press. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Commercial Law - Abe Transport Pty

Admiralty Law as a Combination of Domestic Laws

Knowledge of Admiralty law is necessary for any individual wishing to raise a claim under the law.... his law consists of a combination of domestic laws governing the internal maritime activities and the private international laws.... This law sets the rules and procedures that govern the issues of carriage of passengers and cargos in the high seas and any navigable waters (Ian, 2007 p9).... This law provides the rights and the remedies to all those individuals who encounter injuries within the seas and the inland navigable waters....
18 Pages (4500 words) Coursework

The Ground for Action in Law Opens to Passengers of Lancung Transport

This essay "The Ground for Action in Law Opens to Passengers of Lancung transport" presents the Motor Claims Framework that has been introduced to address the issues of motor vehicles, which had met with accidents.... Here, neither the transport company nor the driver is liable for action (The Law Society of Singapore 2012).... Whether Lancung transport is liable for the action of the driver?... Under the mentioned circumstances, the driver of the transport company is not liable for action under the law since the passengers were at fault, not the driver....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Law (International Business) - Problem Question

In the case of Shipping Corporation of India Ltd v Gamlen Chemical Co (A/Asia) pty Ltd (1980)147CLR 142 (High Court of Australia, 1980), the facts of the case was that the carrier – Shipping Corporation of India Ltd was contracted to transport goods to Gamlen from Sydney in Australia.... “Shipping Corporation of India Ltd v Gamlen Chemical Co A/Asia pty Ltd [1980] HCA 51; (1980) 147 CLR 142 (12 December 1980)”.... The Act indicates that the seaworthiness of a vessel is not limited to the ship itself but includes all the components necessary for safe transport of the goods from the part of departure to the port of destination....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Maritime Law, Bills of Lading, and Charter Party Contracts

The carrier or the master of the shipping vessel has a duty to transport the goods delivered to them with due diligence, in a seaworthy ship and to deliver these goods to the rightful owners as described in the bill of lading which is required to be produced when the goods are delivered to the carrier.... Because the monetary value of the goods that are transported and the time that a ship can take to reach its destination can be substantial, therefore, disputes can arise as a result of the failure of a carrier to discharge its contractual obligations to securely transport goods that have been entrusted in its care....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

International Commercial Terms between 2000-2011

The terms were based on custom–free zones, use of electronic communications, and changes in transport practices.... This essay "International commercial Terms between 2000-2011" discusses the amount of supply and demand between regions while creating a different set of terms and agreements with the new international commercial terms.... he international commercial terms were first identified in the year 2000 when there was an increase and substantial set of changes in logistics and services....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Applicable Laws in International Trade

The guidelines within this section describe the terms related to the packaging of the goods that will be subjected to inland as well as the overseas transport.... his law was enacted as an international trade law with the prime intention of safeguarding the interests of both the insurance agencies as well as the buyers of the goods (Richards Hogg Lindley, 2009; Chuah, 2009).... For instance, the guidelines concerning this law state that the insurance companies will have to provide full coverage to any form of damage to the purchased or the transported goods, only if the damage conditions and the factors do not fall under the clauses 4, 5 6 and 7 (Hodges, 2013)....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Commercial Practice and English Law

Regarding the United Kingdom's commercial law and its relationship with international trade, there is a divided opinion.... Free on board for FOB is a term which is exclusively used for land waterway and sea transport only.... The paper discusses commercial practice from the perspective of English law.... The paper also analyses the 'The authority of an agent to bind his principal' as well as 'Risk for lost or damaged goods where they are sold on FOB or CIF terms', from the standpoint of English law....
13 Pages (3250 words) Literature review

Economics of Air Transport

"Economics of Air transport" paper explains how the UAE aviation industry has impacted its economy.... More than 50% of the tourists and businessmen around the world travel by air and it is the most commonly used mode of transportation than road and rail transport.... The UAE Air Force has been spending tremendously on the defense articles but in order to create a more effective air defense network, they must enhance logistics and management support such as in commercial air transport....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us