StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper describes “A Rose for Emily,” that may be interpreted as a narrative about the Old South, a South which has been battered and defeated by the North and by abolition. It is a South which stubbornly and quite illogically insists on clinging to its former glories…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story"

Borges’ “The House of Asterion” and Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily,” provide rich grounds for comparison and contrast. Irrespective of the fact that they are written from different points of view or unfold within different periods, both explore the theme of isolation and alienation which result from the protagonists’ conviction in their own superiority, on the one hand, and which have been imposed upon them by their own different-ness, on the other. Even though both Miss Emily and Asterion believe that they are in voluntary isolation from their social surroundings and have rescinded contact with others because of their superior status, a critical reading of both stories indicates that they have been marginalized by their surroundings. “A Rose for Emily,” may be interpreted as a narrative about the Old South, a South which has been battered and defeated by the North and by abolition. It is, however, a South which stubbornly and quite illogically insists on clinging to its former glories and, indeed, one which refuses to accept the passage of time, and thus, is left behind. The South is Miss Emily, personified in her refusal to pay taxes and her failure to acknowledge the new reality which surrounds her, culminating in her dismissive treatment of the town’s authorities and her rejection of the very concept of the mailbox/postal services. The South is also the decaying mansion; the mansion which is falling into disrepair but, despite the ravages of time, maintains its haughty, superior demeanor. Last, but not least, the South is Miss Emily’s “negro” servant; the man who silently goes about his duties, keeps Miss Emily’s darkest secrets and when she dies, disappears. The implication here is that the past, as represented in this story, is personified in Miss Emily and her servant and symbolized in the house. She is, as the unnamed narrator insists, “tradition, a duty, and a care; a sort of hereditary obligation upon the town.” She is not, at any time, part of her surroundings and at one with the present, implying the imposition of isolation upon her. In his symbolization of the South as the old, isolated and alienated woman and her `coquettishly decaying’ mansion, Faulkner depicts the old South as, not only dying and decaying but, as a horrific and horrifying anomaly to the present and to the norm. Within the context of the stated, Miss Emily is akin to the un-dead, or death in living. This impression is solidified by the later horrifying revelation, not only of how she murdered Homer Barron but of how she slept with his decaying corpse, then grotesque skeleton. In the days following her death, the `mourners’ open a room which had been supposedly sealed for years to discover, not only the skeletal remains of the murdered Homer Barrett, but evidence that Miss Emily had inhabited this room with the dead. As the narrator says, on the “second pillow was the indentation of a head. One of us lifted something from it, and leaning forward, that faint and invisible dust dry and acrid in the nostrils, we saw a long strand of iron-gray hair.” Horrifying as that image may be, its plot value lies less in its shock-effect than in the fact that it stands out as a powerful symbol of the perversity of allowing the past to subsume the present. As such, “A Rose for Emily,” withstand interpretations as a story whose main theme is the extent to which the rejection of the present and the assumption of superiority leads to loneliness and isolation. Unlike “A Rose for Emily,” Borges’ “The House of Asterion” is written in the first-person, from the protagonist’s point of view. Throughout the story, Asterion maintains that his isolation is self-imposed, that he has voluntarily shunned the outside world. This, however, is quite far from the truth. Certainly, as he insists, the house is unlocked and there are no locks and bolts keeping him in but, his isolation is still involuntary and imposed upon him by the very nature of who he is. As with Miss Emily, his assumption of superiority leads him to reject association with others and, importantly, as the son of a queen, he is set apart from others by his royal blood and, thus, avoided. Added to that, as a Minotaur, he is perceived of as dangerous, bloody and monstrous and, hence, few if any, associate with him. Indeed, the fact that his isolation is as involuntary as was Miss Emily’s is evident in the failure of the “other Asterion” to visit him. Loneliness and isolation in Borges’ story is as involuntary as it was in “A Rose for Miss Emily.” Both protagonists are seemingly incapable of living in the present and with the living and, yet, they appear to crave company. Hence, Miss Emily’s companion is Barrett’s corpse and Asterion’s companions are the men which he killed, the nine men he kills every nine years and places them in different rooms in his house. Within the context of the stated, it is evident that Asterion, like Miss Emily, craves company but as he cannot connect with the living, seeks companionship from among the dead. In closing, both stories draw their plot from the themes of loneliness and isolation. Both protagonists are the partial architects of their own loneliness and misery because their conviction in their own superiority prevents them from associating with others. Nevertheless, they are not the sole architects of the stated since their difference from the majority and the fact that they are little other than social anomalies leads their society to shun association with them. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story Literature review - 1”, n.d.)
Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story Literature review - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1542817-analytical-essay
(Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story Literature Review - 1)
Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story Literature Review - 1. https://studentshare.org/literature/1542817-analytical-essay.
“Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story Literature Review - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1542817-analytical-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Loneliness and Isolation in Borges Story

The Lady of Shalott

He weaves the story as a “lighthearted romantic tale” which eventually turns into the “inexplicable longing and unavoidable death” due to the mention of a curse that changes the fate of the Lady of Shalott (Kruger 39).... The poem takes a sudden twist when she starts resenting her isolation as there is no other way to break the curse except to get involved in it....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

American Literature

A short story is an art form that was first mastered by the 19th-century writer Edgar Allan Poe.... The author of the paper "American Literature" comments on the peculiarities of the American literature.... Reportedly, throughout his book "What is Literature?... Sartre argues that literature is a form of prose writing that engages with the world around it in such a way as to reveal the soul of a writer....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

The Role of Marriage in Persuasion

Though Austen acknowledges that marriage helps prevent loneliness and isolation, she also examines the failures of society's perceptions of marriage which may create an intellectual isolation for women.... The main resistance Wentworth tries to overcome is his desire for Anne and the entire story is based on his resistance to requesting her hand in marriage again.... Early in the story, there is the sense of monotony about the standard way of life as Austen uses repetition in here writing to persuade the reader of that sense of boredom....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

How Elizabeth Bishop Incorporated Her Life Experiences in Her Work

One may say that Elizabeth Bishop's life is characterized by dislocation and isolation.... During adulthood, she found a new home and friend in Brazil, and as a new story tries to unfurl, her Lota de Maceto, perhaps the only friend she's ever had in her life, commits suicide, leaving her alone again.... Instead, every one of her works have been carefully laid out to tell a common story, but always in a highly objective way, always using the third person point of view....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Suicide Before and After

Other times, it is a dull kind of aching, loneliness coupled with a numbing sense of inadequacy.... Sometimes, the pain is sharp and intense - coursing through the body like rivulets of fire.... The pain hits at any given time, and even after several years, even after the shock has subsided, the burden carried by the family members of suicide victims always remain....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Folklore with Witches: The Juniper Tree

In the paper “Folklore with Witches: The Juniper Tree” the author discusses a short story about a small boy born to a man's first wife who is killed by his second wife as a means of securing her husband's fortune.... hellip; This story utilizes a great deal of symbolism to tell the story of divine justice and retribution.... Although it is a story of retribution, the husband and the daughter suffer no ill effects because their participation in the boy's murder was unintentional, unlike the second wife's deliberate entrapment and murder....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The World According to Miranda July

(Horowitz 2005) Artistically preoccupied with the human condition, primarily the weight of loneliness and our desire to relieve that burden through some type of personal connection, Ms....  This paper “The World According to Miranda July” will discuss both the theoretical aspects of her career and touch on biographical milestones of Miranda July, as well as examine one of her primary films....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

The Burden Carried by the Family Members of Suicide Victims

Other times, it is a dull kind of aching, loneliness coupled with a numbing sense of inadequacy.... The paper "The Burden Carried by the Family Members of Suicide Victims" analyze that sometimes, the pain is sharp and intense – coursing through the body like rivulets of fire....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us