StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Burgermeister's Daughter by Steven Ozment - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay discusses the book The Burgermeister's Daughter by Steven Ozment which illustrates life for women during the 16th and 17th century in Germany. The writer articulates a thesis based on gender-differences; the extreme sexism obtaining in 16th century Germany…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
The Burgermeisters Daughter by Steven Ozment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Burgermeister's Daughter by Steven Ozment"

The Burgermeister's Daughter by  Steven Ozment  Introduction: You have, perhaps, never heard a discussion or sermon on the topic, “Men-their role in the society. The discussion is always about women. Men have, perhaps, no role! The arguments on giving equal rights to women have been going on unabated since time immemorial. How can one give equal rights to women? God has created her, given her the status of more-equal. Nobody can take that right away. It is the woman (mother) who gives protection for the initial nine months to the divine creative force of the future-male or female! Steven Ozment’s book illustrates life for women during the 16th and 17th century in Germany. The writer articulates a thesis based on gender-differences; the extreme sexism obtaining in 16th century Germany. Historically, women were mostly treated in only one way—badly! Her trials and tribulations, the restrictions imposed and the duties expected of her were awesome! Most of the rules and regulations weighed heavily against her. Stripped of all rights, society had no standards for her, only double standards to deal with her, and hypocrisy reigned supreme. But this opinion will change if one reads the story of Anna Buschler, who rebelled against the constricting mores of her time. The important issue is the rules of the book and the law of the land allowed her full freedom to carry on with her legal fight. This legal battle lasting for three decades throws profound light on the social, political and intellectual portrait of Germany as prevailed at the end of the Middle Age. As per the social conventions prevailing, “Both men and women were then expected to adhere to clearly defined standards of behavior specific to gender, social class, and contemporary values.”(Ozment, 1997, 2) This epic legal battle between Anna Buschler(1496/98-1552) and her family has done much to unravel the social conditions of that era, more than what any other researched work of a historian would have done. The lawsuit concerned a family, that too between the father and his daughter. The processes involved indicate from the point of women rights that “the centuries between 1300 and 1500 had been something of a golden age for women-their educational and vocational opportunities increased, and with them their civic freedom….” (Ozment, 1997, 5) But the situation changed soon. “….the sixteenth century turned back the clock. Women were again squeezed out of the guilds and public places and increasingly confined to the home—a reversal of fortunes for which some scholars have held the patriarchal ideals of Protestant reformers especially responsible.”(Ozment, 1997, 5) Anna went through a horrid time. She was shackled to a table for six months by her father and the town council jailed her briefly. With no qualms about her being promiscuous, and yet Ozment strongly and convincingly puts forth the view that Burgermeister’s disposition towards her was very severe, Anna emerges great with her fighting qualities. Her resourcefulness must have been admired even by her ardent opponents. Does the story relate to the courage and grit of a woman who challenged the inequalities of that age? It is difficult to totally sympathize with Anna or condemn her outright. Ozment goes all out to the defense of Anna with a zeal that would surpass her most ardent legal counsel (there were none for Anna!) He paints an innocent picture of Anna as for her crimes. The beauty of the court battle, apart from the scope of the dispute is, Anna fought it within the legal framework. Yes, she did violate the codes of conduct of the social order of the era-she is not apologetic about it. She had two affairs and she conducted them simultaneously to earn the wrath of her father. He deprived her of her inheritance. Her drawback was that she had no male to represent her in the court. How quickly the popular opinion changes? Anna lost her case initially because of her affairs. Once she took the case to the city of Hall, it received great publicity, the bad treatment by her father came to light and soon the pubic opinion changed and Herman Bushchler lost his position as burgermeister. The court case went on and on for thirty years, and mind you, a solitary woman fought it, and this certainly is not the testimony to the disempowerment of the women of that era! Not the judgment, but the process of the case itself is victory for the cause of women. For his story, Ozment relies on the evidence of personal letters of Anna and her lovers and scrutinizes the court documents. The story part is good but the resources of Ozment are limited. When clueless, he takes to speculation and then perhaps to desperation. In Chapter 3, Anna brings forth an accusation against her father. Ozment shows a quote out of the court documents from Anna saying that her father "abused her maidenly modesty" (Ozment, 1997, 121). Moral aspect of a new dimension dominates the case. Is the quote taken up to gain sympathy? In any case, less of historical analysis and more of a suspense thriller book takes shape now. Anna’s case would have been more formidable without such an unfounded allegation. But Ozment wishes to chisel a perfect heroine out of Anna, and show her in the best perspective. Now, Anna seems to fight against the indignities of her father than her right for inheritance to property. But Ozment soon realizes that he should not pursue the incest issue. This book is the micro-history of the legal system of the era. That a woman in the rural area owned the courage to continue the legal battle with her more resourceful father is the sterling tribute to her overwhelming courage to be her own against all odds. Ozment traces and emphasizes this merit in Anna with consuming passion and admires her, how ardently she navigated through the legal system for such a long period. She owed no apology to anyone for her sexual relationships, and she charged her father that he failed in his parental duties. He did not look out for a suitable suitor for her well in time. Herr Buschler had risked his life to stop the local aristocracy from bothering and humiliating the ordinary citizens of the Hall. To attribute incestuous desires to such a philanthropist, in relation to his own daughter was highly untenable. With this backgrounder information in mind Ozment rightly ignored the incest. Ozment makes a passing reference to it, and I think, he is absolutely right in exercising restraint on this point. The conclusions/arguments related to the main case-the inheritance issue- would not have changed much, because these are two separate issues. The inheritance case was strictly within the legal frame work and as such arguments on legal points would be put before the judge for consideration. The case made the life difficult for her father and to all concerned. The social standing of Herr Buschler, before he was entangled in to the courts case with his daughter was great. I think Ozment has taken cognizance of this and he made the correct decision. If the father was a man of loose character, he would not have taken such a strong exception to the immoral acts of her daughter, and the shrewd author Ozment knew this arithmetic of human relationships. By raising the incest issue, which had no legal evidence whatsoever, Ozment would have brought the case to an abysmal depth. By avoiding the issue he has provided to the case a modern feel, a permanent place in the history for the cause of rights for women, and made it all the more fascinating. The inheritance case had a dignity about it. It had the latent glory about the womanhood and Anna must have carried the goodwill of the majority of the society. Ozment has dealt with the issue correctly in not taking up the incest issue in detail. He could not marshal the required evidence for such an argument. I feel even the mention of this issue smack of vindictiveness on the part of Anna and it does not serve any tangible purpose for favorable judgment on the inheritance case. They say desperate situations need desperate remedies. Anna must have brought forth this charge, in one of her moods of desperation of conducting such an arduous legal battle. Her strong passion to take the case to a must-win situation is seen in this attempt to provide a new twist to the case. The letters between her lovers and herself and the court records are the evidence secured by Ozment for the book. What is the contribution of her lovers Erasmus Schenk of Limpurg, and Daniel Treutwien for making the life of Anna Buschler utterly miserable is the difficult question to answer, but they have unwittingly contributed a great deal to the history of life in the 16th century Germany. Ozment has taken the maximum advantage out of those letters for his book and he has done it successfully. Conclusion: A difficult, emotionally charging, historically important topic has been well-handled by Ozment. When we compare the gravity of the moral standards violated by Anna, and the intensity of the punishment meted out to her by her father, the scale tilts in favor of Anna and Ozment will be too pleased about this outcome. ============ References: Ozment Steven, The Burgermeister's Daughter: Scandal in a Sixteenth-Century German Town (Harper Perennial; 1st Perennial ed edition 1997) 256 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Burgermeister's Daughter by Steven Ozment Book Report/Review, n.d.)
The Burgermeister's Daughter by Steven Ozment Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1721791-the-burgermeisters-daughter
(The Burgermeister'S Daughter by Steven Ozment Book Report/Review)
The Burgermeister'S Daughter by Steven Ozment Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/literature/1721791-the-burgermeisters-daughter.
“The Burgermeister'S Daughter by Steven Ozment Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1721791-the-burgermeisters-daughter.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Burgermeister's Daughter by Steven Ozment

To a Daughter Leaving Home by Linda Pastan

In the paper “To a daughter Leaving Home by Linda Pastan” the author analyzes the poem by Linda Pastan who conveys the moments of youth when tender years are securely nurtured in the loving ways of motherhood.... hellip; Reading “To a daughter Leaving Home” has brought the author of the paper to a journey of thoughts along the bittersweet memories with his own mother who, like the main character in the poem, has since endured hardships due to his stubbornness even to this point in time....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Rappaccinis Daughter

“Rappaccini's daughter” by Nathaniel Hawthorne is an intriguing tale of unrequited love and heartache where a young couple suffers because of the selfishness of the two rivals Rappaccini and Baglioni.... hellip; Rappaccini's daughter.... “Rappaccini's daughter” by Nathaniel Hawthorne is an intriguing tale of unrequited love and heartache where a young couple suffers because of the selfishness of the two rivals Rappaccini and Baglioni....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Youngest Daughter by Cathy Song

This paper "The Youngest daughter by Cathy Song" focuses on a narrative, free verse poem composed of five stanzas.... It is of a first-person perspective which, based on the title, shows that the speaker is the youngest daughter.... nbsp;  Therefore, without any choice, the youngest daughter has to look after her mother and take care of her, returning all the mother's sacrifices for her, her siblings and even their father.... It is expected of the youngest Chinese daughter not to marry in order for her to be able to take care of the aging parents....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Mother/Daughter Relationships in Literature

In both stories, the mothers' perceptions and values differed from their daughters', with more than the universal mother/daughter relationship problems, such as arguments and rebelliousness.... Two Kinds Amy Tan: June (Jing Mei), the daughter, the first person narrator, vividly expressed Chinese traditional cultural values of her mother, Suyuan, and the differences in perception between mother and daughter....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Rappaccinis Daughter

The short story “Rappaccini's daughter“ appeared in 1844, and potrays a conflict between beauty and sins so typical for most works of Hawthorne.... 24 June 2007 RAPPACCINNI'S daughter The short story "Rappaccini's daughter" appeared in 1844, and potrays a conflict between beauty and sins so typical for most works of Hawthorne.... Beatrice suffers because of fatal experiments of her father who just kills his daughter with poisons in pursuit of medical knowledge....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

The Seven Daughters of Eve by Bryan Sykes

This report talks about The Seven Daughters of Eve by Bryan Sykes.... The discussion stresses that the author provides an easy-to-read account of his own activities in the field of mitochondrial DNA research and the findings those studies yielded.... … According to the paper Sykes presents this tale with the rambling, conversational style of a chum at the bar while presenting key concepts of the science and the evidence to back his claims....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Myth about Demeter and Her Daughter Persephone

This study, Myth about Demeter and Her daughter Persephone, highlights that Greeks and Romans associated all of nature's attributes to a god or a goddess.... These mysteries stemmed from a myth as recounted in one of the Homeric Hymns where Demeter's daughter gets kidnapped and Demeter struggles on getting her backward).... Demeter then strives to get back her daughter.... She then searches for Persephone everywhere and when she eventually finds out that Zeus has control of her daughter, she causes a terrible drought in the area....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

A Bad Time to Raise a Daughter

This essay discusses that raising a daughter in the present day is a great challenge, occasioned by the fact that the rate of growth has greatly increased, the diet has changed, the technology and the social environment is different, while sex has ceased to be a preserve of the married.... hellip; This essay demonstrates that with different factors contributing to the challenges, then there has never been a bad time of raising a daughter than it is today.... This is mostly true when the daughter is at the teenage or adolescent stage of her life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us