StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Proof of God's existence and Human error - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
[Instructor Name] Descartes – Proof of God’s Existence and Human Error Descartes was one of the philosophers that endeavored to prove the existence of God by providing logical reasons. He provided this discussion in his works titled Meditations on First Philosophy…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Proof of Gods existence and Human error
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Proof of God's existence and Human error"

Download file to see previous pages

It is a logical reality that in order for something to be created, someone must create it. According to Descartes, in order for an idea to contain objective reality, it must be derived from a cause that contains at least as much of a formal reality as there is objective reality in the idea. With this logic, Descartes explains that the objective reality of an idea cannot come from a man therefore it must be derived from something else. Only a perfect and infinite being could be capable of creating such an idea, and since man is not infinite, therefore such ideas can never be derived from man.

On the other hand, God is perfect and an infinite being with infinite formal reality, therefore such objective ideas must have come from God; therefore God exists. Second proof of the existence of God is that; the power and action needed to preserve something are the same as needed for creating something anew. Creation of something is an effect and each effect has a cause, therefore there must be as much reality in the cause as in the effect. According to Descartes, man cannot have power to preserve himself therefore the existence that caused the creation of man must be the one preserving the man himself.

Since man can think, the entity that created man must also have the ability to think. Man is not a perfect being and had man been able to create himself, he would have made the man perfect. Since man has ideas of perfection therefore the entity that created man must be perfect. Therefore, through this logical derivation, it can be inferred that God exists. Both these proofs are different from each other due to the perspective through which they are presented. The first proof is presented by using the logic of the infinity of an idea and the cause that created that idea.

On the other hand, the second proof is presented by the logic of the existence of man himself. The second proof is more convincing because it provides an easily understandable logic from the perspective of the existence of humans. Descartes needed two proofs to widen the scope of his philosophy. Proving the same fact using two different dimensions only adds to the depth of the argument. Two proofs are also important because different people with different perspectives may be able to understand them easily.

Two proves do not do different works for Descartes because these are only two ways of proving the same fact. After proving that God exists and he is perfect, there arises a question regarding the imperfection of man. If God is perfect, why is there room for error or imperfection? Descartes presents a convincing argument as a reply to this question which is; there is a scale having two extremes that are nothingness and perfection, and man exists somewhere between these two extremes. Man is less perfect than God but he is more than mere nothingness.

Therefore, error is not a positive reality according to Descartes but it just the absence of what is correct. Thus Descartes infers that man can err without God giving him any ability to do so but error happens only due to the mortality of the ability of the man to judge the truth. Descartes thus describes the existence of human error as the inability of the man to determine why God chose to create the man. It is due to the limited knowledge of the man which is not infinite as that of God. Therefore, it can be said that the arguments presented by Descartes are convincing because he explains the existence of

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Proof of God's existence and Human error Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428936-descartes-proof-of-godyies-existence-and-human
(Proof of God'S Existence and Human Error Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428936-descartes-proof-of-godyies-existence-and-human.
“Proof of God'S Existence and Human Error Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428936-descartes-proof-of-godyies-existence-and-human.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Proof of God's existence and Human error

Discourse on the Method

Therefore, the desire for Descartes to outline a proof about god's existence forces him to apply the skeptical method.... However, Descartes reasoning does not have any error.... During his explorations, Descartes expresses his opinions about imperfection which he regards to be inherent among human beings.... He later discuses the amazements for human's ability to think about perfection.... He asserts that human mind cannot be in a position to understand perfection if at all this notion had been placed by higher being....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

The Debate on Gods Existence

This paper ''The Debate on god's existence'' tells that Over the years, philosophers, theologians, and scientists have engaged each other in the debate on the existence of God.... However, theology and science tend to clash as science disputes the theological approach as inconclusive and invalid because of the supposed loopholes that explain god's existence.... Additionally, the Holy Bible and other holy books provide proof of a higher being than that of man....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Analyze and evaluate

Complete First, analyze and evaluate the two proofs of god's existence.... hellip; Through Meditation III, Descartes brings across two essential inquiries for which the two proofs of god's existence make exact correspondence.... Evidently, the two queries differ in the sense that one ought to be responded to by virtue of proving the existence of God while the second already holds the truth of god's existence yet seeks resolution concerning how God's qualities may or may not suit the act of deception....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Issue of Gods Existence

The paper 'The Issue of god's existence' presents the idea of god's existence that is one of the most, if not the most, controversial ideas that ever crosses the human mind.... hellip; Even in contemporary times, the issue of god's existence is still a major if not the core discourses in the philosophy of which questions such as does exist is still a valid inquiry.... First, the human mind is capable of conceiving the greatest being....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Comparison of the Views of Spinoza and Leibniz on the Nature of God

Things subsist in time; they come into existence and go out of existence.... In what ways can humans know the infinite and eternal aspects of god's essence?... Insofar as one knows the first causes of things, one understands the infinite of god's essence as substance.... How are the first causes of things related to the infinite aspect of god's essence?... By contrast, human knowledge is temporal and finite.... To reach God's knowledge, the human mind must transcend itself to the extent that it grasps God's eternity and infinity....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

The Ontological Argument for God's Existence

The case study "The Ontological Argument for god's existence" states that arguments for the existence of God are varied.... Natural theology based on reasoning is incapable of demonstrating god's existence.... Intellectuals are trying to prove the existence of God through reasoning, and this is the grave error being committed by such individuals.... human beings are likely to confuse the limitations of their thoughts as the limitation of God....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

High Prevalence of Medication Errors

However, its effectiveness is also limited by the fact that IT-based solutions are also limited by technological shortcomings and they also fail to address the human element of the problem.... The author of this paper "Medication Errors" discusses the cases of the incidents of harmful healthcare, the causes of medication errors, the solutions prescribed, and their connection to the cause of these errors, and supportive work, which helps prevent errors at various stages....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report

Thomas Aquinas on the Proof of the Existence of God

In justifying his belief, he came up with five ways that can prove god's existence.... Thomas Aquinas is one of the persons that believe in god's existence.... In justifying his belief, he came up with five ways that can prove god's existence.... To some people, the argument from motion may seem at first glance like anything that easily manifests god's existence, as He is known by Christians, exists.... This report "Thomas Aquinas on the proof of the Existence of God" presents Aquinas that believes in the existence of God....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us