StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Utilitarianism is a common example of theory of ethics.
Utilitarianism theory, introduced by Jeremy Bentham, prescribes a single…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM"

A DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM Ethics is an area of study that comprises countless theories, based on doctrines of performing individual acts either right or wrong and good or bad. Utilitarianism is a common example of theory of ethics.Utilitarianism theory, introduced by Jeremy Bentham, prescribes a single value system and a mode of consequentialism and absolutism, getting the best out of good outcomes for people in shape of pleasure and happiness. Mostly utilitarian theories might seek taking full advantage of other consequences, dealing with the welfare of people.

Therefore, utilitarianism is often related to the term “welfarist consequentialism” (Frost 2004).A good consequence is determined in terms of pleasure or happiness (both intrinsic and instrumental), according to Bentham. So, his concept can also be termed as “hedonic utilitarianism” since he experimented logically that we look for pleasure (hedonism) and avert pain, assuming that both pleasure and pain hold an impact on our decisions, although we are conscious of right or wrong and cause or effect.

Two forms of utilitarianism, act utilitarianism and rule utilitarianism are in conflict with each other. Act utilitarianism, being a results-oriented theory, supports consequentialism, assuming right or wrong on the basis of outcomes. Instead, rule utilitarianism, being an idealistic and inflexible theory, is based on rules involving conduct and related principles. Believers of rule utilitarianism don’t violate the rules, approved by mainstream.Act Utilitarian upholds that the principle of utility must be employed in all individual situations, whenever possible.

Bentham indicates that most vital attributes to determine what is moral are pleasure and pain. The practicality of an action decides its rightness or wrongness, bringing about the utmost good from countless evolving outcomes. For instance, if you are in a state where you consider lying to be a supreme good, at that point, you should lie. If infringement of law leads towards ultimate good of a particular act, then that act would be correct to adhere to. Likewise, Act Utilitarianism allows for flexibility, considering individual situations and identifying the right action strategy to produce extreme happiness.

Conversely, Rule Utilitarianism, associated with John Stuart Mill, concentrates on common rules that each person must obey to lead towards the greatest community benefit. Unlike Act Utilitarianism, Rule Utilitarianism institutes the best rules, followed by the whole community, though it doesn’t head towards the greatest individual pleasure. For instance, in UK, if the road rule is that “you must drive on the left hand side of the road”, this should be adhered to in all situations, whether you want to drive on the right.

You have to obey the rule to keep the traffic in order without pondering over your personal circumstances as is done in act utilitarianism. Mill established that focus should be on the utility of rules instead of single acts. For Instance, he claimed that in definite settings, even if a utilitarian might advocate lying, but it is morally good for society overall to fused with truth telling. Mill preferred ‘pleasures of the intellect’ rather than ‘pleasures of the senses’ (McHugh 2006).

Bentham assumed that what is satisfying is good and what is painful is bad, challenging pleasure as of the ultimate intrinsic value, with anything that assist in getting happiness or avoiding pain as of instrumental value. Unlike him, Mill refuses to accept that people are satisfied with basic pleasures, opposing that pleasures may vary not only in quantity but in quality as well. Likewise, according to Mill, certain types of pleasures are more looked-for and cherished than other pleasures. Moreover, he asserts that the criterion for deciding an act is not the individual pleasure but the ultimate quantity of happiness in total.

Consequently, like Bentham, Mill considers it vital that an individual must not regard his personal satisfaction and happiness more than others’.Consequently, though act utilitarianism and rule utilitarianism have been originated by same theory of ethics but rule theory offers long-lasting basis for the accomplishment of ethical decisions, executing rules for situation types and claiming a right action in harmony with these rules (RunrChic 2011). ReferencesFrost, Martin. Utilitarianism. Martinfrost.ws. 2004.

Retrieved fromhttp://www.martinfrost.ws/htmlfiles/utilitarianism.html McHugh, P.J. ACT and RULE Utilitarianism.TERE (Teachers Enterprise in Religious Education) ORG. 2006. Retrieved from http://www.tere.org/assets/downloads/secondary/pdf_downloads/ALevel/RuleUtilNotes.pdf RunrChic. Act Utilitarianism versus Rule Utilitarianism. Hub Pages. Last updated on February 17, 2011. Accessed at Oct 10, 2012. Retrieved fromhttp://runrchic1.hubpages.com/hub/Act-Utilitarianism-versus-Rule-Utilitarianism

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1604811-detailed-comparison-between-act-and-rule-utilitarianism
(DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1604811-detailed-comparison-between-act-and-rule-utilitarianism.
“DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1604811-detailed-comparison-between-act-and-rule-utilitarianism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM

Moral and Ethics in Philosophy

It also explains why a reasonable man can be detached from his rationale mind and act in passion and later end up regretting his actions.... He pointed out the reflex action of a human being could not have included the mind since the external stimuli activate the nerve ending of the body and force them to act.... He believed this interaction made it possible for the mind to exert influence over the body and make it act in a certain way.... He also stated that the body was also capable of influencing the mind, which is rather rational, and forcing it into action through an act of passion....
4 Pages (1000 words) Literature review

Death Penalty, Kantian Ethics, and Utilitarianism

The supporters of utilitarianism will probably retaliate to this by asking of the specific usefulness of this particular act, i.... This philosophy and its adherents say that people ought to act in... Capital punishment or Death Penalty is still retained extensively around the world, especially in the Muslim nations and United States....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

How Do Ethics Make the Company More Efficient

utilitarianism and utility analysis as used by business vary significantly.... Bentham (1748–1832) is rightly considered the father of modern utilitarianism.... The paper "How Do Ethics Make the Company More Efficient?... considers the ethical firm has higher productivity and attracts new talent....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

John Mills Utilitarianism

hellip; It was but natural that the mantle of (able) Advocate for utilitarianism should fall on his shoulders.... He was, in fact, meticulously groomed by his father and Bentham to carry on the Utilitarian tradition after them. utilitarianism states that the ethicality of an action depends solely on whether it increases overall utility or not.... Therefore, utilitarianism is consequentialism - the morality of an action depended on its outcome, and on nothing else....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Media and Its Responsibilities

Philosophically, a comprehensive analysis of the media and its responsibilities could incorporate the theories of utilitarianism, virtue ethics and deontology.... In the course of carrying out many of these responsibilities, the media may also play the role of activism in defending the vulnerable and clamoring for… Over the times, many injustices have been redressed through the unrelenting focus of the media....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Different Ways of Solving Ethical Problems

utilitarianism believes in doing well to the maximum number of people (Smith, 2010).... The paper "Different Ways of Solving Ethical Problems" states that various theories on ethical marketing further reinforce the fact that companies should abide by ethics in their marketing activities....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Personal Identity and a Certain Level of Importance in Every Individuals Life

The network can act as a variable that changes behavior.... he importance of this relationship can easily be seen when social networking is the main form of communication between certain close relatives.... This is because comparison shopping is easy (Degeratu et al 2011)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Death Penalty, Kantian Ethics, and Utilitarianism

The author of this paper "Death Penalty, Kantian Ethics, and utilitarianism" discusses the question of whether the death penalty must deter, no matter what statistics say because almost everybody would prefer life in prison to execution, analyzing the utilitarian approach, the Kant's philosophy.... On the other hand, the ethics in utilitarianism are based on the preference of the majority.... he supporters of utilitarianism will probably retaliate to this by asking of the specific use of this particular act, i....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us