StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The SAT Reasoning Test - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research paper “The SAT Reasoning Test” aims to investigate into why the present SAT design is not an appropriate indicator of a student’s capabilities and intelligence and why it needs to undergo further changes…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
The SAT Reasoning Test
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The SAT Reasoning Test"

The SAT Reasoning Test Introduction The SAT Reasoning Test was developed first by Carl Brigham to test the mental ability of army officials (Wooller, 2004). After 80 years of the first test conducted by College Board, this standardized test is now used as a main criterion of admission in almost all top universities all over the world. This paper aims to investigate into why the present SAT design is not an appropriate indicator of a student’s capabilities and intelligence and why it needs to undergo further changes. Why SAT Needs Further Redesign? According to Karen Huffman in her book ‘Psychology in Action’, the scientific standards for a good Psychological Test to measure intelligence are standardization, reliability and validity. Standardization is when norms and uniform procedures must be established for giving and scoring in a particular test. Reliability includes that the test should be such that measures stable and consistent scores when the test is administered the second time and lastly validity is when the results measure what the true purpose of conducting the test was (Huffman, 2007). SAT is standard for everyone and is also reliable at the same time. But when it comes to validity, some people argue that the results of the test do not show the true intelligence of the person. Why is this so? According to K12 Academics, which is an Education Resource Centre, the analogies in the verbal section are ambiguous and there are errors in scoring of math scores. However, in 2001 Richard C. Atkinson urged the American Council of Education to drop SAT Reasoning test as a college admission requirement. He recommended making this test optional. Because of this, in 2005, the pattern of the SAT Reasoning test was changed. (K12 Academics, 2008) In 2006, the average national score of the SAT dropped by seven percentage points from 2005. This was the largest drop in 31 years and was reported in the ‘Yale Daily News’ by Josh Duboff (2008). An article published in 2007 by Maya Srikishnan, who is a reporter for ‘The Daily Texan’, reports that this new and improved test also got criticized because of its writing section. This section required students to write an essay in 25 minutes. The students argue that this does not show colleges their full potential, as 25 minutes is not enough to write something worth being in a college application. Also this test puts people who do not have English as their first language at a disadvantage as a bigger portion of the test now required the students to know English. This new test was also condemned because of the duration of the test. Students and educationalists argue that the test is too long and this affects the scores of students (Srikishnan, 2007). In short, the new test is argued to be even less valid than the older one. There have also been a lot of errors in the calculation of the final scores. In 2006, it was reported by ‘The Daily Gamecock’ that all together out of 495,000 tests, 4411 tests had been incorrectly marks. This error in checking makes the test unreliable to some extent. (Pope, 2006) In an article ‘Test Bias: The SAT in the College Admissions Process’ written by Susan Woollen, she reports that College Board itself emphasizes that SAT should not be used as a main criterion of admission and that it is wrong to determine the grade point average, class rank and other qualities in a student by just considering the score of SAT. She also argues that the questions in SAT are also culturally biased towards Blacks and Hispanics. In 2002, the average score of a white American was 527 in verbal and 533 on math section while blacks scored an average of 430 in verbal and 427 in math. This proves that when the scores of different ethnicities were compared, there was a huge difference and according to Susan and her sources, this difference is because of the cultural biased design of SAT. The minorities kept scoring consistently lower than whites. However, this could be because of the quality of education and low housing conditions that are given to the minorities. (Wooller, 2004). Therefore SAT should be designed in such a way that will not only increase the accuracy of the results but will also eliminate cultural differences. On the other hand, College Board argues that the new SAT design will project what the students actually need to know at that point. (Trojan, 2005). According to K12 Academics, SAT II which is also called SAT Subject Tests have said to be more content oriented which gives the students more opportunity to show their true potential in the subject they consider themselves to be good at. (K12 Academics, 2008) Also, for instance when there are 20 students with equal good grades; the SAT should then be used to decide on which one to be selected. Steve Vogel in 2007 indicates in his article that SAT’s present design is useful in measuring a student’s reasoning and critical thinking skills. Plus the SAT also tests a student’s ability of answer questions quickly as time constraint is also there. Lastly, it also helps improve a student’s vocabulary. Conclusion After considering both the sides, we come to the conclusion that even though SAT may have some benefits, but the criticism of SAT is valid and the SAT must therefore undergo further redesign which will make it less culturally biased, more accurate and valid. Till then it should not be the only indicator of a person’s success. According to Charles Buchanan the score of the SAT should be important but at the same time the most important factor that should be considered while giving admission should be the academic record of the student in high school. College Board must pass this point to parents and teachers and other universities so that everyone has equal opportunities when it comes to admission in universities. (Buchanan, 2001) WORK CITED 1. “New SAT could have benefits for colleges.” Daily Trojan. 23 Feb 2005. 2. Pope, Justin. “College Board endures sharp criticism on SAT”. The Daily Gamecock. 24 March 2006. 3. Charles Buchanan, “SAT not the best indicatior of Success” UCLA Today. 2001 4. Maya Srikishnan. “College Board faces criticism for new SAT section”. The Daily Texan. 13 April 2007. 5. Josh Duboff. “Criticism of SAT rises after average score decreases dramatically”. Yale Daily News. 6 September 2006 6. Susan Wooller, “Test Bias: The SAT in the College Admissions Process”. 2004 7. K12 Academics. 2008 8. Karen Huffman. “Psychology in Action”. 2007 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The SAT Reasoning Test Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
The SAT Reasoning Test Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1546238-argument-essay
(The SAT Reasoning Test Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
The SAT Reasoning Test Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1546238-argument-essay.
“The SAT Reasoning Test Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1546238-argument-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The SAT Reasoning Test

Analysis of the exam for admission to higher education institutions

hellip; The SAT Reasoning Test was developed first by Carl Brigham to test the mental ability of army officials (Wooller, 2004).... Because of this, in 2005, the pattern of The SAT Reasoning Test was changed.... Atkinson urged the American Council of Education to drop sat reasoning test as a college admission requirement.... In 2006, the average national score of the sat dropped by seven percentage points from 2005.... (Pope, 2006) In an article 'Test Bias: the sat in the College Admissions Process' written by Susan Woollen, she reports that College Board itself emphasizes that SAT should not be used as a main criterion of admission and that it is wrong to determine the grade point average, class rank and other qualities in a student by just considering the score of SAT....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Mozart Effect in Childrens Toys

9 and shipping. In 1993 Rauscher, Shaw and Ky published results of a study in which they measured the increase of spatial reasoning skills in 36 college students who listened to music composed by Mozart.... The researchers reported increases of between 8 and 10 points on the IQ spatial reasoning task scale as opposed to those students who sat quietly for the 10 minute period or listened to relaxation tapes.... (1997), however, conducted a two-year study where they found that preschool children who took piano lessons had increased spatial reasoning skills....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

The Ultimate Program for Gifted Learners

When a child is born he brings with him a set of new thoughts, ideas and talents.... It is a grand and invigorating experience.... He is a gift of God not only to the parents but to the entire neighborhood.... A bundle of joy, he is a source of boundless amusement in the family and the neighborhood who shower him with love and affection. … The years roll, the child grows to be a youth and then an adult....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Surgery for an Inguinal Hernia

I have no essay criteria.... have to critically anaylise the work in this title.... This is a presentation to a group.... I dont have time to prepare for this.... Let me know if you need more information and I will try to help.... Many thanks Melanie Lister.... Harvard Hernia is an abnormal protrusion of whole or a part of a viscus through an opening in the wall of the cavity in which it is contained....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

How Many Students Took the Law School Admission Tests

A study conducted by Domino & Domino established that 54% of those students who passed the LSAT actually proved that the test was valid.... Most countries are also adopting the same strategy as a way of standardizing applicants and assuring law schools that they admit applicants whose… The schools that have made it mandatory requirements for students to take the LSAT in the U....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Impact of Music on Human Development

This paper "The Impact of Music on Human Development" evaluates the claims of various researchers who have studied the impact of music in helping a student in learning.... And for this paper, music has been found to help people to read, concentrate, and remain focused on their studies.... hellip; Music has an intrinsic value to young people as well as an adult....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

College Entrance Exams - Do They Predict Undergraduate Success

Many researchers argue that both the sat and ACT are redundant, and unfair means of assessing the individual skills of minorities, women, and secondary English speakers.... Later on, the Scholastic Aptitude test or SAT came into the limelight owing to the convenient testing method is offered.... Most of the test takers are middle to upper class, Caucasian, native English speaking males.... here are different methods adopted by a range of colleges for weighing standardized test scores....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Performance of the USA in the Scholastic Assessment Test

hellip; The author states that one of the most widely known and intensively examined aptitude test for higher education is the sat.... the sat gives two scores, the mathematical and verbal scores.... It is also known that the maximum score for each part of the sat is 800 and the minimum 200.... ince 1926, the sat was administered annually and only in 1994 that a major revision was made, including its meaning.... The major changes to the sat were documented by Steven Graff (1993), project director of the working group responsible for the redevelopment of the sat....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us