StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Literary criticism of article on The Ehics of Genetic Engineering - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In a position paper on the ethics of genetic engineering, David Koepsell argues for the benefits of genetic engineering to the exclusion of its alleged harms. The author does not see the new advances in biological technology as a potential ethical problem, assuming that it is “appropriately regulated” (Koepsell 19)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful
Literary criticism of article on The Ehics of Genetic Engineering
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Literary criticism of article on The Ehics of Genetic Engineering"

Download file to see previous pages

In fact, people have more to fear from the restriction of this technology in the sense that giving up on its benefits, in favor of outdated moral arguments, could lead to more harm than good. Although Koepsell prescribes regulation in order to control potential abuses of this technology, he does not provide a political or scientific framework for managing the risks associated with genetic engineering and gives a rather cursory look at the moral arguments against new technologies. With these weaknesses in mind, one should nonetheless take Koepsell’s warnings seriously, as they are not only applicable to genetic engineering but a wide variety of novel fields in the application of scientific research.

The author begins by giving the basic science behind genetic engineering, which includes basic information about DNA, genes, and genetic disorders. He also approaches the issue of ethical challenges, including the secular and non-secular objections to genetic engineering. Secular arguments tend to focus on dignity at the species level. However, this objection fails in that there is no room for non-arbitrary distinctions between human DNA and the DNA of other species. Consistency in this case requires hands-off for both human DNA and that of crops.

The non-secular arguments tend to focus on genetic engineering as something opposed to “nature”. . This cost/benefit analysis is presumed to have moral significance because it focuses specifically on things that human beings value most. If genetic engineering is beneficial to all of these different areas of human life, then it necessarily must be good. Koepsell devotes some attention to drawbacks of the technological advances; however, the only drawback that is addressed is the inherent unpredictability of genetic crossbreeding between engineering and non-engineered genomes.

This is exemplified both in human populations, where gene therapies can have potentially harmful effects on populations, and in agriculture, where the spread of genes is more uncontrollable and less conscious. However, Koepsell’s section on drawbacks is not as positive as one might hope: it is interspersed with language like “will improve,” “scientific breakthrough,” and “testing should be employed” (Koepsell 13-15). One can tell immediately that this section on drawbacks is not a value-neutral account of the actual dangers of the technology, but is rather fodder for the author’s arguments for more research.

Appropriately, this section leads into considerations of “justice” and “equity,” which are two primary ethical concerns of scientific research. The author considers straw-man situations such as those found in science fiction to dispute the theory of a genetically-derived underclass, and begins to acknowledge the difficulty of trusting policymakers to provide “rational oversight and regulation of germline modifications in humans” (18). The purpose of regulation, the author contends, is to provide a just and equitable distribution of benefits to a society.

Accordingly, instead of having only the rich able

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Literary criticism of article on The Ehics of Genetic Engineering Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/biology/1432040-literary-criticism-of-article-on-the-ehics-of
(Literary Criticism of Article on The Ehics of Genetic Engineering Essay)
https://studentshare.org/biology/1432040-literary-criticism-of-article-on-the-ehics-of.
“Literary Criticism of Article on The Ehics of Genetic Engineering Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/biology/1432040-literary-criticism-of-article-on-the-ehics-of.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Literary criticism of article on The Ehics of Genetic Engineering

The Nature of Genetic Diseases

The purpose of the following article "The Nature of genetic Diseases" is to provide a scientific definition of genetic disorders.... Moreover, the article describes the underlying causes of genetic diseases as well as contemporary tendencies in its diagnosing and treatment.... Another cause of genetic disorders is chromosomal errors.... While man travels as far off as planet Pluto to discover the Universe we live in, it is the study of the body and its genetic makeup that is the breakthrough of the century....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Human Engineering

The process of genetic screening and selection aids in pre-determination of the genetic anomalies of the child.... Individuals who possess anomalies that are heritable are benefitted from such kind of genetic testing followed by selection of the baby.... The author of this paper states that human engineering encompasses designing human tasks as well as machines for the efficient execution of the work as well as to provide a complete understanding of the human systems....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Is Genetic Testing Right for You and Your Family

Critique In his article, Harold Pollack makes vital assertions that may raise questions on the ethics and morality of genetic testing.... hellip; In his article, Harold Pollack discusses the complications that arise from genetic testing.... genetic testing Introduction genetic testing or DNA testing is a vital procedure used in healthcare to determine the prevalence of hereditary health complications.... In his article, Harold Pollack discusses the complications that arise from genetic testing....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Genetic and society

Simplot Company engineering the potato says the potato has genes such as bacteria and promises of its health benefits (Pollack, para.... The Innate potato The article from the New York Times analyses the economic and health effects of genetically modified food.... It brings into perspective an innate potato genetically modified to abuse harmful ingredients amounts in potato chips and French fries....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

New Clues to Genetics of Type 2 Diabetes

It is important that the causes, whether genetic or otherwise, are known as this will help with the education of both medical personnel and their patients as to the best way to deal with the condition.... This article “New Clues to Genetics of Type 2 Diabetes” is concerned with Type 2 Diabetes, its consequences, its causes and in particular to what extent and why is it more common among certain people groups than in other groups....
15 Pages (3750 words) Article

Understanding of Different Literary Techniques

The paper 'Understanding of Different Literary Techniques' highlights Rhetorical analysis which is an in-depth study of an article such as a speech or essay with the view of determining the author's strategic employment of words in order to influence his or her audience.... By appealing to the audience, the authors improve the target audience for their article.... Emotional appeal is essential in developing an article since it influences the readership to identify with the plot and themes in the article, thereby sympathizing with the author....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

Comprehensive High-Throughput Arrays for Relative Methylation

Moreover, it implies that technology would lead to the discovery of several other facts in genetic engineering studies.... The article of Irizarry, Ladd-Acosta, Carvalho, Wu, Brandenburg, Jeddeloh, Wen and Feinberg (780) suggested that their research objective of discovering the effective tool to identify the genomic locations has been a major success in the field of genetic alteration and epigenetic.... Respectively,… However, their recent study revealed that these two genetic factors in the field of carcinogenesis are the same....
3 Pages (750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us