“One Art” and “My Heart Will Go On” Comparative Essay
The poem “One Art” and the song “My heart will go on” are pieces of art with evidence of rhyming poetic style in them (Cunningham 5). Similar sound in both the poem and the song has been achieved through repetition as well as rhyming words. For instance, there is evidence of repeated words and phrases in the poem that gives it quatrain, including “losing”, “lost”, and “loss”. Similarly, the song “My heart will go on,” exhibit repetition to yield assonance including, “go on”, “heart”, and “gone.” Besides, the poem has a master, disaster, and fluster as rhyming, while the song has rhyming phrases such as “see and feel”, and “You’re and here”. Therefore, although rhyme has been developed in the song and the poem, it has been obtained by varied styles (Cunningham 7).
Since songs and poems communicate to their audience in short words, their organization should be developed to allow them to reflect their meaning. As such, both the case poem and music have a ballad structure, since they comprise of short verses. The case music can be thought of as a romantic poem, but it has a mid-tempo tune that calls for the sluggish pronunciation of phrases like “my heart will go on”. On the other hand, the case poem has a Villanelle format in that it has six stanzas each of which has three lines apart from the last verse that has four lines.
Evidently, the ballad configuration that the two pieces of art in this case have is vital in portraying their meaning of love. Bearing in mind that the song “My heart will go on” was composed to be the theme song for the movie “Avatar”, its meaning is, therefore, developed as that of a lover mourning for the departure of a loved one. Similarly, for the case poem, the poet is lamenting over the parting of a lover. Therefore, based on their meaning, both “My heart will go on” and “One Art” have a similar theme.
It is crucial to note that the poem “One Art”, has developed its meaning by the villanelle structure, whereby each stanza develops a case and a conclusion, but after the conclusive third line of the last section, a fourth line recaps the whole poem. Therefore, the last line in the “One Art” poem has reflected on its meaning. On the contrary, the ballad organized song, in this case, does not appear to have a rhyming number of lines per stanza. The evidenced varying number of lines in the song is a unique order that allows the tune of music to reflect on its meaning.
As the tone in poetry is used to instill emotions so as to enhance the meaning, there is a similarity in the tone of “My heart will go on” and “One Art”. One point of similarity is the manner that resonance has creatively been used in the two cases to develop the feelings of mourning (Ellis 118). Moreover, the two pieces of art have incorporated imagery and symbolism to enhance a remorse tone. For example, the poem symbolizes an individual who has lost most of her valued belongings, yet she does not regret it, but she laments for losing her loved one. In the like manner, the song uses the illusion of a loved one opening the door of the heart and going to a distant place. Evidently, through imagery and the remorse tone, both “One Art” and “My heart will go on” have captured their meaning of remorse on losing a loved one.
The song “My heart will go on” and the poem “One Art” has a similar ballad structure. However, the two poetic arts products have differences in the manner of their reflection and tone achievement.
Cunningham, Valentine. Victoria Poetry Now: Poets and Poetics: New York. John Willey & Sons, 2011
Ellis, Jonathan. Art and Memory in the Work of Elizabeth Bishop. FarnHam: Ashgate Publishing, Ltd. 2006