StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Mixed Member Proportional Representation - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of this paper states that mixed-member proportional representation is also known as mixed-member proportional voting and commonly abbreviated to MMP. It is nothing but one of the most important voting systems…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Mixed Member Proportional Representation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Mixed Member Proportional Representation"

 Mixed Member Proportional Representation Introduction Mixed member proportional representation is also known as mixed-member proportional voting and commonly abbreviated to MMP. It is nothing but one of the most important voting systems used to elect representatives to numerous legislatures around the world. MMP is similar to other forms of proportional representation in that the overall total of party members in the elected body is intended to reflect the overall proportion of votes received. However, it is different from prportional representation as it includes a set of members elected by geographic constituency who are deducted from the party totals so as to maintain overall proportionality. It took different shapes in different countries. While examining its relevance in Canada, one must analyze its nature in some countries like United Kingdom and Germany. MMP is partially implemented in United Kingdom and is commonly known as the additional member system (AMS). Similarly, in Germany it is called as personalized proportional representation. Opinion of some authors regarding MMP Different theories emerged during last five years regarding the pros and cons of mixed member proportional voting system. However, it is relevant in the present context to examine the views of some authors like John L. Hiemstra, Harold J. Jensen, Christopher Kam, Mark Charlton and Paul Barker regarding the prospects of implementing mixed member proportional representation in Canada (Mark Charlton and Paul Barker. 2005). John L. Hiemstra and Harold J. Jensen opined that the implementation of mixed member representation system certainly benefits the democratic set up of Canada as it allows better representation of higher number of people while progressing towards people’s development. However, they felt that the minor modifications in the existing MMP by taking the experience of some countries like South Africa, Venezuela, New Zealand and Bolivia where MMP is already in practice. By implementing the positive aspects of MMP, Canada would certainly get benefited significantly and the voters would be in a position to derive maximum benefit from democracy. At the same time, more favoring comments from Christopher Kam (2006) encourages the government functionaries of Canada to implement this MMP system immediately with out any second thought. They further pointed out the limitations of the existing voting system in the form of non-uniform representation and hence favored electoral reforms immediately in the form of MMP. However, they cautioned that the people’s awareness regarding the structure of MMP should be enhanced, otherwise, it may result in negative effects. It was observed that the lack of sufficient knowledge on structure and rules of MMP in countries where it was initially implemented led to confusion among the voters and hence resulted in false voting questioning the basic essence of MMP. My views on MMP in Canada It is certainly essential to implement MMP in countries like Canada as it facilitates the higher representation of major sections of the society in more meaningful manner. The general procedure for MMP in Canada must be as follows: The total number of seats in the assembly may be allocated to parties proportionally to the number of votes the party receives in the party portion of the ballot. At the same time, subtracted from each party's allocation would be considered as the number of constituency seats that party wins. The number of seats remaining allocated to that party would be filled using the party's list. However one must note that in case a candidate is on the party list, but wins a constituency seat, they do not receive two seats. They would be crossed off the party list and replaced with the next candidate down. This would allow uniform representation of voters compared to the present system followed in Canada. However, some variants based on the previous experience of MMP in other countries may be considered. The favoring factors for MMP in Canada are as follows: 1. MMP was recommended in Canada by some notable commissions after studying various factors. For example, in March 2004 the Law Commission of Canada proposed a system of MMP for the Canadian House of Common. However it was not adopted by the government. It was also unfortunate to find that the proposal to adopt MMP for elections to the Legislative Assembly of Prince Edward Island was defeated in a referendum in 2003. 2. Most importantly, recent deveIopments are in favor of its implementation in Canada as the Citizens' Assembly on Electoral Reform in Ontario, Canada, opined in favor of the use of MMP in future elections to the Legislative Assembly of Ontario. It recommended a ballot similar to that of MMP in New Zealand. It gives us again a disappointing feeling that this proposal was again defeated in conjunction with the provincial election in secon week of October, 2007. It doesn’t mean that the efforts of considering MMP have to be left in the present state, but to critically analyze the factors of MMP in Canada. One must not forget the fact that the public opinion on implementation of MMP has been increasing in its favor day by day and they are debating it regularly. 3. As the voter makes two votes i.e. one for a constituency representative and one for a party it gives immense scope for broader representation. The MMP in Canada can take the best results of Germany. In Germany, both votes were combined into one, so that voting for a representative is nothing but also voting for the representative's party. It is important to note that Germany transformed to the two-vote variant to make local MPs more personally accountable. Hence it will aid in successful implementation of MMP in Canada. As proposed by some commissions to follow the MMP model of New Zealand, Canada would get tremnedously benefited as it was observed that in New Zealand's last election, 20% of local MPs were elected from electorates which gave a different party a plurality of votes. It otherwise ensures more diverse representation and efficient functioning of government. The negative factors for implementing MMP in Canada are as follows 1. MMP implementation may result in overhang seat problem. It can happen due to the fact that a party can gain fewer seats by the party vote than needed to justify the won constituency seats. It is a common problem as opined by several commissions as Canada is expected to folllow the model of New Zealand which already faced this overhang seat problem. In New Zealand's 2005 General Election the Māori Party won 2.1% of the Party Vote, entitling them to 3 seats in the House, but won 4 constituencies resulting in an overhang of 1 seat, which results in a 121-member house instead of a normal 120-member house. However overhang seats may be tackled if Canada follows the example of the British and Italian models where proportional allocation is applied only to list seats. 2. There is a potential for tactical voting in MMP If MMP is implemented in Canada, there is a probability of occurrence of tactical voting which means that the vote for the constituency representative is normally much less important than party vote in determining the overall result of an election. At the same time, a party may be so certain of winning seats in the constituency elections that it expects no extra seats in the proportional top-up. It gives the scope for some voters to go for a double representation by voting tactically and splitting their votes. 3. There is a scope of manipulation from side of political parties under MMP. MMP, if implemented in Canada may face the problem of splitting of a single political party in to two or more for their tactical advantage. They may separate their party in to two. One contests the electorates seats, where as the other contests for the list seats resulting in an overhang. This may benefit them in getting more party funding. But it is detrimental in terms of meaningful representation of all sections of canadian society. 3. There is also a problem of voter confusion due to lack of awarteness regarding MMP in Canada. As the present awareness of people regarding MMP is quite low, there is possibility that they may be confused and vote for a wrong candidate. Conclusion Overall, the implementation of MMP certainly benefits the democratic set up of Canada in several ways. What ever the shortcomings, that may arise can be tackled by making necessary amendments or variations to the general structure of MMP based on the experiences of other countries. References: Christopher Kam. 2006. "Demotion and Dissent in the Canadian Liberal Party." British Journal of Political Science 36: 561-74. Mark Charlton and Paul Barker. 2005. Contemporary Political Issues, 5th edition. Nelson college Indigenous publication. ISBN-10: 0176415157. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Mixed Member Proportional Representation Term Paper, n.d.)
Mixed Member Proportional Representation Term Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1542614-proportional-representation
(Mixed Member Proportional Representation Term Paper)
Mixed Member Proportional Representation Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/politics/1542614-proportional-representation.
“Mixed Member Proportional Representation Term Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1542614-proportional-representation.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Mixed Member Proportional Representation

Democratic Deficit in Canada

To view the current system of the Canadian political scene and highlighting the factors that affect the people of Canada and their desire for a change of the political scenario in regards to their choices and decisions. … William Dunn (British parliamentarian) claims to have first used the term to describe the difference between the EU and the citizens of its member countries....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Voting System in the UK General Elections

After Labour Party won the 2005 general election of UK with the support of only a fifth of the adult population, Health Secretary Patricia Hewitt publicly called for a debate on reforming the voting system in the country.... Her remarks came amidst growing demands by political campaigners for a review of the voting system (Russell, 2005)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Electoral Reforms in Canadian Provinces

It will then examine the various proposals put forward for reforms such as the Alternative Vote (AV), Two-round or run-off system, list-proportional representation, Single Transferable Vote (STV), Mixed Member Proportion (MMP), and Mixed Member Majoritarian (MMM) systems.... An essay "Electoral Reforms in Canadian Provinces" reports that this is due to the use of FPTP method of electing candidates....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Comparative governance

Among the 28 member states of EU, the UK is said to have a proportion of women MPs which is considered fifteenth.... The benefits of participation of men and women in an equal proportion in local government and parliament issues are considered to be numerous.... It helps the government to represent… There are numerous benefits of representative government such as engaging diverse communities, drawing on the skills of a group which is very broad, and managing the use of political power efficiently....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

New Zealand Politics

From the paper "New Zealand Politics" it is clear that even if prisoners account for a small percentage of voters, the range of views of their voting entitlement ensures that the issue becomes a “political football” whenever there are reform suggestions.... hellip; Only the New Zealand adult citizens and permanent residents can vote, provided they meet the required residential requirements and are not subject to disqualification under the Act....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Why Should We Care So Much About How Votes Are Translated into Seats

hellip; The proportional representation System in Europe has continually gained popularity.... here are usually three electoral formulas, which are Majoritarian, Plurality, and proportional representation.... The last method is that of proportional representation in which the seats are allocated between the parties in proportion to the percentage of votes they have received.... Generally, many countries follow a proportional representation (PR) method rather than the other two....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Electoral Reform: Motivations and Implications in the European Context

The author concludes that electoral reform is a positive political exercise.... The manner by which governments react to it and its outcome simply reflect the nation's level of maturity and depth of the nation's understanding of the democratic principles to which this electoral institution stands for … As revealed in the above discussion all electoral reforms are motivated by the dissatisfaction of a larger group....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Mixed-member Proportional Representation System

This paper ''The Mixed-member proportional representation System'' tells that There are several voting systems used around the world, such as the mixed-member proportional representation system.... This comes along with the feeling of inadequate representation.... The same minor parties can be incited to be divisive and extreme because with just 5% votes, representation is guaranteed....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us