StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Relationship between Television Violence and Aggression - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Relationship between Television Violence and Aggression" tells that the former Chairman of the Senate Subcommittee on Juvenile Delinquency, Senator Estes Kefauver, conducted investigations in 1954 on whether television violence was aggravating cases of violent activities in the U.S…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
The Relationship between Television Violence and Aggression
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Relationship between Television Violence and Aggression"

? Television Violence Essay Introduction The debate about the relationship between television violence and aggression has been intense for several decades now. The former Chairman of the Senate Subcommittee on Juvenile Delinquency, Senator Estes Kefauver, conducted investigations in 1954 on whether television violence was aggravating cases of violent activities in the U.S. (Watson & Martin, 2011). When asked, network owners retorted that the existing studies were inconclusive. After several decades, several government documents and a huge number of empirical studies present compelling evidence that television violence can have adverse impact on viewers (Grimes, Anderson, & Bergen, 2008). This essay presents an overview of the arguments for and against the relationship between television violence and aggression. Television Violence Promotes Aggression There is a growing number of evidence that exposure to television violence is positively correlated to the development of aggressive behavior. There are three major arguments that help demonstrate how television violence can influence aggression. The first argument is referred to as social learning or observational theory. As argued by psychologist Albert Bandura, children acquire new behaviors through observing and imitating other people in their immediate social environment or through direct experience. Children observe the behavior of television characters and may afterward imitate these actions, particularly when the child idolizes and relates to the character (Van Der Voort, 2009). Children are likely to imitate violent actions that are effective in achieving the character’s goals. The more realistic television violence is for the child the more s/he will identify with the characters, and the more s/he will try to imitate their behavior (Van Der Voort, 2009). Numerous field and laboratory studies over the recent decades have investigated whether children exposed to television violence act more aggressively. Paik and Comstock carried out a meta-analysis of television violence studies. They discovered a highly positive correlation between television violence and aggression. The strongest impact was found in preschool children, and the impact for males was somewhat greater than it was for females (Feshbach & Tangney, 2008). The second argument, called cognitive scripting, was introduced by Huesmann. Cognitive scripts are “mental routines that are stored in memory and are used to guide behavior” (Watson & Martin, 2011, 1007). Huesmann discovered that television violence gives viewers scripts that promote aggressive behavior. These scripts, once acquired or learned, can be recovered from memory at whatever time. When a violent script is recovered, it can be strengthened and expanded to a new set of situations (Slotsve et al., 2008). Therefore, frequent exposure to violent scenes in television can persuade children to adopt a set of constant cognitive scripts that highlight aggressive behavior as a usual reaction to social circumstances. The third argument focuses on how the television could encourage or activate already acquired or learned aggression. The ‘excitation transfer theory’ of Zillmann argues that television violence can have an effect basically because it is stimulating in nature (Savage & Yancey, 2008). The argument states that exposure to television violence can arouse excitement that, since it dissolves gradually, can move or expand to other emotional domains; if an individual is already aggressive or furious an arousing violent television program can intensify those emotions and thus enhance the possibility of aggressive reaction (Grimes et al., 2008). According to Feshbach and Tangney (2008), due to its stimulating attributes, Zillmann has concluded that even erotic television shows can reinforce aggression in upset or resentful individuals. Television Violence Does Not Promote Aggression Other empirical evidence suggests that television violence and aggression are associated but that a causal relationship is nonexistent. In effect, both television violence and aggression may be due to a third variable such as gender, peer pressure, cultural and social factors (Freedman, 2007). Martinez argues that even those who claim that there is a positive correlation between television violence and aggression differ about the strength of the correlation and the degree to which the one influences the other. A great deal of causal effect research reveals a positive, but inconclusive or weak, correlation between exposure to violent media content and aggression (Grimes & Bergen, 2008). The first argument states that even though exposure to television violence may trigger aggressive behavior, causation may also run in the opposite way. As argued in the ‘selective exposure’ theory, children with a psychological or biological inclination toward aggression may be attracted to the violent media content more than children with a low inclination toward aggressive behavior (Van Der Voort, 2009). Numerous studies substantiate the selective exposure theory. For instance, a 10-year study of children identified as ‘emotionally disturbed’ discovered that even though these children were exposed to a great deal of television violence and liked aggressive characters better, they were no more likely to act violently immediately after watching violent television shows than nonviolent television programs (Grimes & Bergen, 2008). A research in Northern Ireland looked at exposure to television violence and aggressive behavior among young and adult sibling pairs. More aggressive pairs had a tendency to prefer violent television shows more than less aggressive pairs, but no evidence of the influence of television violence on differences in intra-pair behavior has been found (Grimes et al., 2008). A second argument states that some feature of the child’s personality may act together with television violence to elicit the child’s aggression. Hence, children who are inclined toward violence or aggressive behavior or who are in some way more ‘susceptible’ may respond aggressively to television violence, while other children may not (Grimes et al., 2008). Furthermore, originally aggressive children who are greatly exposed to violent media content would be likely to display later increase in aggressive behavior in comparison with either originally aggressive children who are not exposed to violent television shows or originally non-aggressive children who are very much exposed to television violence (Grimes & Bergen, 2008). The third argument, referred to as the catharsis theory, states that aggressive behavior will be lessened after exposure to violent media content. Allegedly through catharsis, the tendency toward aggression is reduced through exposure to television violence (Watson & Martin, 2011). This theory argues that the emotional impulse stimulated by violent television shows lessens the likelihood of a child actually behaving aggressively; the imagined behavior and fantasy play of a child lead him/her to have weakened desires to behave aggressively (Van Der Voort, 2009). In essence, the catharsis theory claims that watching violent media content is a healthy way of releasing negative emotions and is thus beneficial for the mind. Conclusions The evidence from both sides of the debate thus far makes it logical to assume that exposure to television violence is one source of aggression, particularly in some groups of children and particularly in boys. However, a causal relationship between exposure to violent television shows and behaving aggressively is not unavoidable and may not always be long-term. Moreover, there are numerous situations where in the impact does not arise. Environmental factors, personality attributes, peer influence, and parents may reduce or heighten the impact of exposure to television violence. In fact, not all viewers perceive violence similarly, and not all viewers are similarly susceptible. The most susceptible could be young boys, particularly the ones who are originally predisposed to aggression. References Feshbach, S. & Tangney, J. (2008). Television Viewing and Aggression: Some Alternative Perspectives. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3(5), 387-389. Freedman, J. L. (2007). Television violence and aggression: setting the record straight. The Media Institute. Retrieved November 10, 2011, from http://www.mediainstitute.org/new_site/PDFs/policyviews/Freedman-TelevisionViolence.pdf. Grimes, T., Anderson, J., & Bergen, L. (2008). Media violence and aggression: science and ideology. New York: Sage Publications. Grimes, T. & Bergen, L. (2008). The Epistemological Argument against a Causal Relationship between Media Violence and Sociopathic Behavior among Psychologically Well Viewers. American Behavioral Scientist, 51(8), 1137-1154. Savage, J. & Yancey, C. (2008). The Effects of Media Violence Exposure on Criminal Aggression: A Meta-Analysis. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 35(6), 772-791. Slotsve, T., del Carmen, A., Sarver, M., & Villareal-Watkins, R., J. (2008). Television violence and aggression. Southwest Journal of Criminal Justice, 5(1), 22-49. Van Der Voort, T. (2009). Television Violence: A Child’s Eye View. New York: Elsevier. Watson, R. & Martin, C. (2011). Handbook of Behavior, Food and Nutrition. New York: Springer. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Television Violence Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Television Violence Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1478349-television-violence
(Television Violence Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Television Violence Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1478349-television-violence.
“Television Violence Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1478349-television-violence.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Relationship between Television Violence and Aggression

Media Violence and Aggressive Behaviour

his investigative study will aim to establish a relationship between television viewing preferences, particularly violence, and their consequent impact on behaviour.... The paper "Media violence and Aggressive Behaviour" discusses that there has been a significant impact of perception of violence among the participants as they have been watching television portray aggressive behaviour as a positive and acceptable element.... This research does point in the direction of a causal relationship between violence on television and increased aggression at later stages in life....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Violent Childrens Programs

This paper 'Violent Children's Programs' examines, analyzes, and explains violent children programming from a content analysis perspective as it relates to network shows such as Nick, Disney, and Toon as far as the extent of violence and the contexts in which it occurs has been consistently high.... Continuous watching of television may manipulate viewers' ideas of what the daily world is all about and even induce some violent behaviors in children by changing their general mindset about violence....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Crime and Violence on Television and Its Impact on Wider Audiences

pecifically,the hypothesis presented in the paper asserts that viewing of violence and crime on television is positively correlated with an increase in violent behavior on the part of the audience.... Specifically, the hypothesis presented in the paper asserts that viewing of violence and crime on television is positively correlated with an increase in violent behavior on the part of the audience.... The primary reasons governing the positive correlation between the viewing of violence on television and an increase in violent behavior on the part of the audience include; the audiences' ability to relate to the characters portraying violence and the extent to which they are able to develop an association between the virtual world of television and reality (Huesmann et al....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Causes And Effects Of Violence On Television

This establishes a connection between media violence and aggression.... This establishes a connection between media violence and aggression.... There are many studies that indicate a definite relationship between viewing violence and aggressive behavior.... Ross conducted a study by exposing the first group of children to real-world violence, second group of children to television violence, third group of children to cartoon violence and fourth group watching nothing....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Exploring the Violence in Television and Its Effect on Childrens Psyche

How extreme is the problem of violence on television Does it transmit aggressive behavior to children Does it affect their psychological health This paper will try to tackle the link between TV violence and aggression to young viewers and try to analyze what are the possible solutions that can be done to thwart the incremental effects of violence in television.... "Accidental" violence and "acts of nature" are recorded because they are always purposeful in fiction, claim victims, and demonstrate power (p....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Video Game Violence and Aggression

This paper "Video Game violence and aggression" focuses on the propensity of our nation's people toward violence and aggression that has been cited as a psychological, social and public health issue.... This reaction is an extension of the general concern about the effects of media violence and television viewing.... The studies were evaluated separately based on each of these ages categories, as well as the type of research design and the type of outcome measure of aggression used....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Connection Between Media Violence and Aggressive Behavior

In trying to understand the relationship between violent media and aggressive behavior in children Savage (2004) looks to the perspective put forward by Huesmann in 1986 who argues that ' the most plausible hypothesis is that habitual exposure to violent television programs teachers children aggressive habits which are maintained well into adulthood' (Savage, 2004.... This coursework "The Connection Between Media violence and Aggressive Behavior" focuses on people who have been concerned about the effect that media violence can have on children's behavior and whether there is a connection between the media violence and aggressive behavior....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Should Sex and Violence on Television or in the Movies Be Restricted

The author of the "Should Sex and violence on Television or in the Movies Be Restricted" paper argues in favor of regulating sex and violent materials on television.... The creative community or the television program producers are often blamed for excessive violence, sex, and indecent language on television.... For that purpose, they are including more sex and violence-related programs even at the prime time.... They will try to imitate whatever the attractive scenes they might have come across when watching television programs and sex and violence in television programs can easily derail the development of the children....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us